Employment law

Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers v Kenya National Library Service [2026] KEELRC 15051 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E129 of 2024
Judgment date
12 November 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before the Court is a Statement of Claim dated 15th February, 2024, where the Claimant seeks the following orders as against the Respondent: -

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

In the final analysis, I find the Claimant’s Claim devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed in its entirety with no orders on costs.

Paragraph 73 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered whether the Employment and Labour Relations Court had jurisdiction despite the grievant earning below Kshs. 80,000 per month; whether unpaid outpatient medical allowance was proved; and whether salary arrears claimed for the 2018…

Material facts

The union sued on behalf of Jonah Gachoki Nyaga, a Grade 14 Senior Subordinate Staff member employed from 11 January 1991 until voluntary early retirement effective 3 March 2020. He experienced ill health, was placed on sick leave in 2018, underwent Medical…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E129 OF 2024.

KENYA UNION OF COMMERCIAL,

FOOD AND ALLIED WORKERS .............................................CLAIMANT

VERSUS

KENYA NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICE ............................. RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction.

1. Before the Court is a Statement of Claim dated 15th February, 2024, where the Claimant seeks the following orders as against the Respondent: -

a. His unpaid outpatient medical allowance for the period May 2016 – September 2016 and from August 2018 – March 2020 totaling Kshs. 26,880/=

b. Payment of his outstanding net half months wages for January 2018 – March 2018 and unpaid full Net salaries for April 2018 – September 2018 or: –

i. Half salary Kshs. 12,586 x 3 months = Kshs. 37,578/=

ii. Full Salary Kshs. 25,172 x 6 months = Kshs. 151,032/=

c. The total of prayer (i) and (ii) above is Kshs. 215,188/=

d. Plus, payment of his salary arrears and arrears of allowances arising from the 2012 – 2013 and 2013 – 2017 Collective Bargaining Agreements.

e. An order of this Court do issue directing the Respondent to work out and file the grievants’ salary arrears and arrears of allowances arising from the 2012 – 2013 & 2013 – 2017 Collective Bargaining Agreements for adoption by this Honourable Court.

f. Interest to accrue at Court rate on all outstanding payments from the date of default until full settlement.

g. Costs of the suit in quantified amount be awarded to the Claimant as the Claimant acts by self and cannot benefit from the Advocate’s Remuneration Order.

h. Any other relief the Honourable Court finds fit and just to grant.

2. The Respondent entered appearance on 18th March, 2024 and filed a Statement of Response dated 20th March, 2024. The Respondent subsequently filed a Witness Statement by Elias Ireri Kamwere, together with its List and Bundle of Documents dated 26th May, 2025. It also filed a Further List of Documents dated 21st October, 2025. The Respondent later filed a substituted Witness Statement by Albert Nyabuto Nyamunda, its Deputy Director of Human Resource Management, dated 25th May, 2026.

3. Both the Claimant’s case and the Respondent’s cases were heard on 26th May, 2025. The Claimant’s case was heard through CW1, Jonah Gachoki Nyaga, who adopted his Witness Statement dated 15th February, 2024 and produced his List and Bundle of Documents of even date as Claimant’s Exhibits Nos. 1-17.

4. The Respondent called RW1, Albert Nyabuto Nyaundo, to testify in support of its case. He adopted his substituted Witness Statement and produced the Respondent’s documents as Exhibits Nos. 1-12, together with a further document admitted as the Respondent’s Exhibit No. 13.

5. Both parties filed written submissions.

The Claimant’s Case

6. The Claimant’s case is that the grievant, Jonah Gachoki Nyaga, was employed by the Respondent on 11th January, 1991 as a Watchman at Job Scale 1, earning a starting salary of Kshs. 1,110/= per month. It avers that he was initially posted to Embu Area Library and was subsequently transferred to Timau Branch where his position was redesignated as Senior Subordinate Staff, Grade 14. The Claimant contends that the grievant remained in the Respondent’s employment until his voluntary early retirement on 3rd March, 2020.

7. The Claimant avers that the grievant became unwell in or around 2016 and required regular medical attention. It states that his condition persisted and that, on 4th May, 2018, he was placed on sick leave and referred to the Medical Board for assessment to determine his fitness to continue working.

8. The Claimant states that the Medical Board’s report dated 20th September, 2018 identified cerebral atrophy and chronic frontal subdural hematoma, and although the Medical Board recommended that he was fit to resume duty, the Claimant maintains that he continued experiencing the effects of his condition.

9. The Claimant states that the Respondent lifted the grievant’s sick leave through a letter dated 18th October, 2018 and directed him to resume duty at Timau Branch. It further avers that the Respondent failed to pay the grievant’s full salary during the period of sick leave and the period following the lifting of the sick leave.

10. Specifically, the Claimant states that the grievant was not paid outpatient medical allowance for May to September 2016 and August 2018 to 3rd March, 2020. It also claims that the grievant received only half salary for January to March 2018 and was not paid his full salary for April to September 2018.

11. The Claimant further contends that the Respondent failed to pay salary and allowance arrears arising from the CBAs covering July 2012 to June 2013 and July 2013 to June 2017. It states that the grievant was a unionizable employee covered by the applicable CBAs and was therefore entitled to the salary adjustments and allowances provided therein.

12. The Claimant avers that the grievant sought payment of the outstanding amounts through correspondence with the Respondent, including a letter dated 4th March, 2018 and another dated 26th August, 2018. It states that he subsequently applied for early retirement by letter dated 16th August, 2019, which the Respondent approved by letter dated 4th February, 2020, with retirement taking effect on 3rd March, 2020.

13. The Claimant states that the dispute was referred to the Ministry of Labour for conciliation after the Respondent failed to settle the alleged outstanding amounts, and a conciliator was appointed, and the parties attended the conciliation meetings, but the conciliator did not issue a report or certificate of conciliation, prompting the Claimant to institute the present proceedings.

14. On cross-examination, CW1 confirmed that he retired from employment and was not terminated. He confirmed that he was a Senior Subordinate Staff member at Grade 14. He maintained that he was not paid medical allowance for the period May to September 2016.

15. He referred to the payslips at pages 9-11 of the Respondent’s bundle relating to May to September 2016 and maintained that he did not receive the medical allowance for the relevant period. He further stated that he did not know how to read and could not read the circular suspending the medical allowance.

16. CW1 was referred to the Respondent’s payslips at page 14 of its bundle for October 2019, and he maintained that he was not paid the outstanding amounts. He also stated that he received only half salary for January to March 2018 and referred to pages 86 -89 of the Respondent’s bundle, which contained his payslips.

17. He acknowledged that he experienced ill health and was sometimes unable to report to work, but further stated that he was not granted three months’ sick leave and was only allowed one month. He confirmed that the Respondent’s management referred him for medical tests because he was unwell and that he returned to work in October 2018 after the hospital indicated that he was okay.

The Claimant’s submissions

18. In its submissions, the Claimant submits that the dispute concerned non-payment of medical allowances for May to September 2016 and August 2018 to March 2020, together with salary arrears arising from the grievant’s sick leave in 2018.

19. On medical allowances, Counsel initially pleaded an amount of Kshs. 26,880/= but in the submissions, revised the claim by taking into account the payment of Kshs. 14,560/= reflected in the Respondent’s October 2019 payslip. The Claimant submits that the payslips the Respondent produced for May to September 2016 were neither proper payslips nor payroll extracts capable of proving payment, as they did not indicate the relevant payment dates. It therefore maintains that the medical allowance for that period remained unpaid.

20. The Claimant therefore submits that the total revised claim for medical allowance was therefore Kshs. 12,320/=.

21. On the salary arrears, Counsel relied on Clause 5.10.1 of the Respondent’s Human Resource Manual which provides for full salary during the first three months of sick leave and half salary for the subsequent three months.

22. It was submitted that the provision did not state that an employee would cease to be entitled to salary after the six months expired. The Claimant further submits that the grievant was entitled to full salary for May to July 2018 and full salary upon being cleared to resume duty and that the Respondent’s own payslips demonstrated that full salary was not paid for the periods claimed.

23. It is the Claimant’s submission that, after taking into account the amounts already paid, Counsel calculated the outstanding salary balance for May to July 2018 at Kshs. 32,880/= and the balance for August and September 2018 at Kshs. 28,544/=, making a total outstanding salary claim of Kshs. 61,424/=.

24. The Claimant expressly withdrew the claim for CBA salary arrears for the period 2012-2017. Counsel therefore urged the Court to award the revised medical allowance and salary arrears totaling Kshs. 73,744/= together with interest and costs.

The Respondent’s Case.

25. The Respondent states that the grievant was its employee under Payroll No. 641, but denies that the amounts claimed under the various heads remain unpaid.

26. The Respondent admitted the grievant’s attendance before the Medical Board, but denies that his travel and other expenses were not paid. It further maintains that the grievant was paid all his dues and denies the claims relating to medical allowances, salary and CBA arrears.

27. The Respondent further states that the claim is time barred under Section 90 of the Employment Act and consequently the Court lacked jurisdiction to hear and determine the same. It further contends that pursuant to Gazette Notice No. 6024 dated 10th June 2018 published in the Kenya Gazette on 22nd June 2018, the matter ought to have been filed before the Magistrates’ Court because the grievant was earning less than Kshs. 80,000/=.

28. RW1 maintained that the grievant was paid the medical allowance for May to September 2016 through the routine monthly payroll. Regarding the period August 2018 to March 2020, he explained that the Respondent’s Board decided to discontinue the medical allowance in anticipation of implementing comprehensive medical cover for all employees. It avers that the comprehensive medical cover was, however, not implemented due to financial constraints, and the outstanding medical allowance was subsequently paid in the October 2019 payroll.

29. RW1 further testified that the grievant was in and out of work due to ill health and was placed on sick leave for three months from May 2018. He stated that under Clause 5.10 of the Respondent’s Human Resource Manual, an employee on sick leave was entitled to full salary for the first three months, and half salary for the following three months.

30. RW1 maintained that the grievant was duly paid half salary for January to March 2018 and that he was still unwell after the expiry of the initial three months of sick leave, hence the payment of half salary. He further stated that the grievant was erroneously paid full salary in April 2018 and that the overpayment was recovered in subsequent payments.

31. RW1 stated that the grievant was referred to the Medical Board for assessment and that the report dated 24th September, 2018, received on 9th October 2018, cleared him to resume work. RW1 maintained that the grievant was paid his October 2018 salary and that salary payments thereafter resumed normally.

32. RW1 also stated that the grievant subsequently lodged a complaint with the Labour Office in September 2020 following which a conciliator was appointed. He maintained that the Respondent cooperated with the conciliator and presented evidence that the grievant was paid all his dues, but the grievant became uncooperative, and no conciliation report was prepared.

33. On cross-examination, RW1 confirmed that the grievant’s medical allowances for May to September 2016 were paid according to the payslips produced.

34. RW1 confirmed that the grievant was paid full salary for January 2018. However, when referred to pages 36-40 of the Respondent’s bundle, he confirmed that the May 2018 payslip reflected zero basic salary, the June 2018 payslip reflected half basic salary, while the July, August and September 2018 payslips reflected zero basic salary. He also acknowledged that salaries for June to September 2018 were not paid.

35. RW1 confirmed that the grievant was placed on sick leave, which was lifted on 18th October, 2018, and that he was entitled to earn salary upon resumption of duty. He further confirmed that the October 2018 salary was paid and stated that the arrears reflected in the October 2019 payroll related to medical allowance. He also confirmed that the medical cover ceased in October 2018.

36. On re-examination, RW1 explained that the basic salary reflected in the payslips at page 36 was not paid for April 2018 because the grievant was to receive half salary while on sick leave, although he stated that the grievant was on duty in April and was therefore entitled to full salary for that month.

37. RW1 further referred to the medical allowance arrears for the period August 2018 to September 2019 and maintained that the grievant was not owed any outstanding arrears.

38. The Respondent prays that the Claimant’s case be dismissed with costs.

The Respondent’s Submissions

39. On the validity of the payroll and payment records, the Respondent submitted that the Claimant’s allegation that its records were fabricated was unsupported by evidence. It was argued that the Claimant has not produced any independent financial records such as bank statements to demonstrate that the payments reflected in the Respondent’s payroll records were not made. The Respondent therefore urged the Court to treat its payroll and payment records as credible evidence of the payments made.

40. On the medical allowance, the Respondent submitted that the allowance for May to September 2016 was paid, as demonstrated by the payslips marked EIK 1. In respect of August 2018 to March 2020, the Respondent explained that the Board suspended the allowance in anticipation of introducing comprehensive medical cover, but the proposed cover was not implemented due to financial constraints.

41. The Respondent maintains that the outstanding medical allowance was subsequently settled in the October 2019 payroll as demonstrated by the payslip marked EIK 3. It therefore disputed the Claimant’s assertion that the medical allowance remained unpaid.

42. On the salary arrears for January to March 2018 and April to September 2018, the Respondent relied on Clause 5.10 of its Human Resource Manual which provided for full salary during the first three months of sick leave and half salary for the next three months. Counsel submitted that the grievant was absent from duty for extended periods on account of ill health, and that the Respondent applied the applicable provisions of the Manual in computing his salary during the relevant period.

43. The Respondent further submitted that the grievant exhausted his sick leave entitlement and was referred to the Medical Board for assessment, and upon being found fit to resume duty, he was cleared to return to work in October 2018 and salary payments resumed from that month. It maintains that the Claimant has not established any contractual or legal basis for claiming full salary during the period when he was entitled to half salary or had exhausted his sick leave entitlement.

44. The Respondent consequently submitted that the Claimant has failed to prove entitlement to any of the alleged outstanding sums and urged the Court to dismiss the Statement of Claim in its entirety with costs.

Analysis and Determination.

48. I have considered the pleadings, the evidence tendered by the parties, the written submissions and the witnesses’ oral testimonies. The issues arising for determination are:

i. Whether this Court has jurisdiction to entertain the claim.

ii. Whether the Claimant has proved entitlement to the unpaid medical allowance.

iii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the claimed salary arrears arising from the period of sick leave.

Whether this Court has jurisdiction to entertain the claim

45. The Respondent challenged the jurisdiction of this Court on the basis that the grievant earned less than Kshs.80,000/= per month and that, pursuant to Gazette Notice No. 6024 of 2018, the claim ought to have been instituted before the Magistrates' Court.

46. The jurisdiction of this Court is founded on Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution and Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act.

47. As correctly submitted by the Respondent, Gazette Notice No. 6024 of 2018 designated Magistrates of specified ranks to exercise jurisdiction in employment and labour relations matters within the prescribed pecuniary limits.

48. Specifically, Gazette Notice No.6024 (CXXNo.74) of 22nd June, 2018 provides thus: -

“In Exercise of the powers conferred by section 29 (3) and (4) (b) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, 2011, and in consultation with the Principal Judge of the Court, the Chief Justice appoints all Magistrates of the rank of the Senior Resident Magistrates and above as Special Magistrates designated to hear and determine the following employment and labour relations cases within their respective areas of jurisdiction:

Disputes arising from contracts of employment (excluding trade disputes under the Labour Relations Act, 2007) (emphasis own) where employees' gross monthly pay does not exceed Ksh80,000.00 as commenced and continued in accordance with the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2016….”

49. By dint of the foregoing, it is clear that some employment matters were delegated vide the Gazette Notice to the Magistrates Court with the exception of labour disputes, which were exclusively retained within the mandate of this court.

50. Section of the Labour Relations Act, 2007, defines a trade dispute as follows: -

“trade dispute” means a dispute or difference, or an apprehended dispute or difference, between employers and employees, between employers and trade unions, or between an employers’ organisation and employees or trade unions, concerning any employment matter, and includes disputes regarding the dismissal, suspension or redundancy of employees, allocation of work or the recognition of a trade union”

51. By dint of the foregoing provisions, it is clear that a dispute between a trade union and an employer such as the one in this matter can only be entertained by the Employment and Labour Relations Court and not the Magistrates' Courts as suggested. In Public Transport Operations Union v Solex Motors Limited (Cause E571 of 2023) [2025] KEELRC 3645 (KLR), the Court held that a dispute instituted by a trade union on behalf of its members constitutes a trade dispute under the Labour Relations Act, and falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of the ELRC and is not subject to the Kshs.80,000/= pecuniary threshold under Gazette Notice No. 6024 of 2018.

52. The Claimant has brought the case herein on behalf of its member in its capacity as a registered trade union and having a recognition agreement with the Respondent.

53. This, in effect, means that the suit herein is a trade dispute, and this Court no doubt has jurisdiction.

Whether the Claimant has proved entitlement to the unpaid medical allowance

54. The Claimant initially sought Kshs.26,880/= as unpaid outpatient medical allowance, but subsequently revised the claim to Kshs.12,320/= after taking into account the payment of Kshs.14,560/= reflected in the October 2019 payslip.

55. The Respondent’s position is that the medical allowance for May to September 2016 was paid through the monthly payroll. It further explained that the allowance for August 2018 to September 2019 was suspended pending the introduction of comprehensive medical cover, but was subsequently reinstated and paid through the October 2019 payroll.

56. The Respondent produced payslips for May to September 2016 which it relied upon to demonstrate payment of the allowance. The Claimant challenged their evidential value on the ground that they did not indicate the dates on which payment was made. However, the mere absence of payment dates on the payslips does not, without more, render them invalid or establish that the amounts reflected therein were not paid.

57. In Wanjohi v SGA Security Solutions Limited [2022] KEELRC 3852 (KLR), the Court considered the evidential value of payslips in establishing employment entitlements and observed that payslips constitute relevant employment records capable of demonstrating payments and accrued benefits.

58. The Respondent's evidence that the outstanding medical allowance for August 2018 to September 2019 was paid in October 2019 is also supported by the October 2019 payslip, which the Claimant acknowledged during cross-examination.

59. I am therefore not persuaded that the Claimant has established, on a balance of probabilities, that the medical allowance reflected in the Respondent's payroll records remained unpaid.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to the claimed salary arrears arising from the period of sick leave

60. The Claimant's revised claim for salary arrears was Kshs.61,424/=, comprising Kshs.32,880/= for May to July 2018 and Kshs.28,544/= for August and September 2018.

61. The Respondent's position is that the grievant's salary was computed in accordance with Clause 5.10 of its Human Resource Manual, which provided for three months' sick leave on full pay, followed by three months on half salary.

62. Section 30 of the Employment Act provides for sick leave on full pay and half pay, subject to the statutory conditions. An employer may, however, provide more favourable sick leave benefits through its employment policies or contractual arrangements.

63. In Kennedy Nyanguncha Omanga v Bob Morgan Services Limited [2013] KEELRC 810 (KLR), the Court recognized that an employer may provide sick leave benefits that are more favourable than the statutory minimum and that such benefits should be honoured.

64. In the present case, Clause 5.10 of the Respondent's Human Resource Manual provided for full salary during the first three months of sick leave and half salary during the subsequent three months. The Respondent was consequently bound to apply its own policy when computing the grievant's salary.

65. Significantly, RW1 admitted during cross-examination that the grievant's May 2018 payslip reflected no basic salary, the June 2018 payslip reflected half basic salary, while the July, August and September 2018 payslips reflected no basic salary. He further acknowledged that the grievant was entitled to salary upon resumption of duty and that he was on duty in April 2018, when his salary ought to have been paid in full.

66. These admissions, in my view, expose inconsistencies in the Respondent's explanation that the grievant's salary was properly computed under the Human Resource Manual. The Respondent did not satisfactorily explain why it paid no salary for May and July 2018, when the grievant was admittedly entitled to full salary under its own policy, or why it did not pay the salary for August and September 2018 at the applicable half-rate.

67. Further, under Sections 10(7) and 20 of the Employment Act, an employer bears responsibility for maintaining and producing employment and remuneration records.

68. I therefore find that the Respondent did not satisfactorily demonstrate that the grievant's salary was correctly computed and fully paid during the relevant period.

69. Having said that, however, the non-payment of salary is no doubt a continuing injury, and the claim ought therefore to have been instituted within twelve months after the cessation of the injury. The grievant retired on 3rd March, 2020, and the claim was therefore required to be instituted no later than March 2021.

70. In Isandula v Friends Church (Quakers) Nairobi Yearly Meeting (Civil Appeal 35 of 2019) [2023] KEELRC 2513 (KLR), the Court emphasized that claims for salary arrears must be considered against the dates on which the alleged defaults occurred.

71. Further, the fact that the grievant previously raised the outstanding payments through correspondence or subsequently referred the dispute to the Labour Office does not, without an express statutory basis, suspend or extend the limitation period.

72. I accordingly find that the claims for salary arrears are statute-barred and cannot be entertained by this Court.

73. In the final analysis, I find the Claimant’s Claim devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed in its entirety with no orders on costs.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 12TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Muunda present for the Claimant

Mr. Okech present for the Respondent

Ms. Esther S - C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder