Criminal law

Republic v Mathenge [2026] KEHC 16944 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Case number
Criminal Case E023 of 2026
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
J W W Mongare

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Accused has been charged with the offence of Murder contrary to section 203 as read with section 204 of the Penal Code (Chapter 63 of the Laws of Kenya). The particulars are that on 11th May 2026, at Kware area,Matungulu Sub-County within Machakos County, jointly with others, he murdered Feisal Ali Swaleh. The Accused denied the charge and the court directed that a Pre-Bail Report be prepared before it can be determined whether he…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The upshot is that the Accused is denied bail at this point. However, he may seek re-consideration of the issue of his bail at a later stage of the proceedings, in case of changed circumstances such as when the community tension has subsided and/or key witnesses have testified. It is so ordered.

Paragraph 7 →

Reasoning passage

Having gone through the Information, the Pre-Bail Report and the principles of bail outlined above, the court is of the view that denying the Accused bail at this point would be judicious and appropriate in the circumstances. As stated above, the Accused is charged with the offence of Murder which carries a penalty of death and I find that the gravity of this charge alone is a significant compelling reason to deny bail as the incentive…

Paragraph 4 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether Migel Njoroge Mathenge, who denied a murder charge, should be released on bail or bond pending trial, or whether compelling reasons justified withholding bail at that stage.

Material facts

The accused was charged with murdering Feisal Ali Swaleh on 11 May 2026 at Kware area, Matungulu Sub-County, Machakos County, allegedly jointly with others. He denied the charge. A pre-bail report recorded community tension and enmity between youths from the…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS

CRIMINAL CASE NO. E023 OF 2026

BETWEEN

REPUBLIC…………………………………………………………….PROSECUTOR

AND

MIGEL NJOROGE MATHENGE………………..….…………………..ACCUSED

RULING ON BAIL

1. The Accused has been charged with the offence of Murder contrary to section 203 as read with section 204 of the Penal Code (Chapter 63 of the Laws of Kenya). The particulars are that on 11th May 2026, at Kware area,Matungulu Sub-County within Machakos County, jointly with others, he murdered Feisal Ali Swaleh. The Accused denied the charge and the court directed that a Pre-Bail Report be prepared before it can be determined whether he can be released on bail or bond pending the hearing and determination of this case. The Pre-Bail Report has been filed and I have considered the same in this determination.

2. I do not think it is in dispute that Article 49(1)(h) of the Constitution grants an accused person the right to be released on bond or bail on reasonable terms and conditions pending trial, unless there are compelling reasons not to be released. Further, the Bail and Bond Policy Guidelines formulated by the Judiciary requires courts in granting bail to take into consideration, inter alia, the facts and circumstances of each case; and to balance the rights of an accused person against the interests of justice. It is also not lost to the court that the granting of bail is an exercise of discretion (see Babayao v Republic [2019] KECA 93 (KLR)]

3. Lesiit J., (as she was then) in Republic v Zacharia Okoth Obado [2018] KEHC 4109 (KLR), cited the court’s (Emukule J.,) decision in Republic v Milton Kabulit & 6 Others [2011] KEHC 2839 (KLR) that set out compelling reasons for declining bail as including:

i. nature of the offence,

ii. strength of the evidence, which supports the charge,

iii. the gravity of the punishment in the event of conviction,

iv. the previous criminal record of the applicant,

v. the probability that the accused may not present or surrender himself for trial,

vi. the likelihood of further charges being brought against the accused,

vii. the likelihood of the accused interfering with the witnesses or may suppress any evidence that may incriminate him,

viii. the probability of finding the applicant guilty as charged,

ix. the detention for the protection of the accused,

x. the necessity to procure medical or social report pending final disposal of the case.

The court also cited Criminal Procedure Bench Book at para. 105 which outlines non-exhaustive compelling reasons to include; likelihood accused may fail to attend court; may commit or abet the commission of a serious offence; endanger the safety of victims; interfere with witnesses or evidence; endanger national security or public safety; and protection of the accused person. This court has also always stated that the prosecution has the burden of proving compelling reasons to justify the denial of bail (see Republic v Gahohi & 2 others [2026] KEHC 10530 (KLR)]

4. Having gone through the Information, the Pre-Bail Report and the principles of bail outlined above, the court is of the view that denying the Accused bail at this point would be judicious and appropriate in the circumstances. As stated above, the Accused is charged with the offence of Murder which carries a penalty of death and I find that the gravity of this charge alone is a significant compelling reason to deny bail as the incentive to abscond is inherently high. The Pre-Bail Report also explicitly states that the local administration is opposed to bail because "….there is still tension in the community due to enmity between the youth from the area where the accused resides and those from the deceased's side." The Probation Officer warns that if the Accused is released, "…his security is not guaranteed" and “…it may fire up anger that may result to lethal retaliation." It is not lost to me that the court has a duty to protect the Accused's life, as well as maintain public order.

5. The Victim's family is opposed to bail because "…there are other suspects involved who are still at large." Furthermore, they claim that the deceased's younger sibling witnessed the incident and that if the Accused is released, there is a demonstrable risk that he might interfere with these witnesses or collude with the suspects who are still at large.  The Probation Officer, after analyzing the social findings, explicitly recommends that "the accused bond be delayed to a later date when the tension cools down." The Pre-Bail Report also notes that in early 2026, he was charged with assault in Kangundo and granted cash bail of Kshs.50,000.00, which he complied with. While this shows he is not a serial absconder, the current charge is far more serious and the surrounding community tension is significantly higher. Furthermore, whereas there are other factors that favour the Accused such as him being a low flight risk as he has a fixed abode and his family is willing to ensure he attends court, the risk of community retaliation and witness interference currently trumps the low flight risk.

6. In summary, I find that the Prosecution has successfully established compelling reasons under the Milton Kabulit(supra) framework, specifically regarding the protection of the accused, public safety and the likelihood of interfering with witnesses. The Probation Officer's recommendation to delay the bond until tension cools down is a sensible, discretionary middle-ground that respects the Accused's constitutional right to bail while prioritizing immediate safety and the integrity of the trial.

7. The upshot is that the Accused is denied bail at this point. However, he may seek re-consideration of the issue of his bail at a later stage of the proceedings, in case of changed circumstances such as when the community tension has subsided and/or key witnesses have testified. It is so ordered.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED virtually this 22nd DAY OF OCTOBER

2026

............................................................................

J W W MONGARE

JUDGE

In the presence of;

1. Accused/Applicant is Present at Machakos Main Prion

2. Ms. Machuma for the Respondent/DPP

3. Abdisalan- Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder