Civil law

Mutua & another v Bukachi & another [2026] KEHC 17458 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Case number
Civil Appeal E193 of 2026
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
Noel I. Adagi

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling is on the Applicants’ Notice of Motion application dated 9th October 2026 seeking for orders that:-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have carefully considered the application, the replying affidavit the trial court’s judgement and oral submissions by the Parties’ Advocates. The only issue for my determination is the place of deceased’s burial. Whether I should stay the burial of the deceased herein at Matetani in Kangundo Sub-county as directed by the trial court pending the hearing and determination of this appeal.

Paragraph 8 →

Decision / orders

In the end, I find that the trial court rightly considered the Parties’ respective cases and the evidence in support thereof and rightly found that the 1st Respondent had proven the deceased’s wish to be buried at his ancestral land in Mukunuku village, Matetani, Kangundo Sub-county, Machakos County as directed in his Last Will and Testament dated 22nd October 2025 which qualifies the required standard under the doctrine of the…

Paragraph 32 →

Reasoning passage

In the circumstances, it is my finding that the judgment of the trial court is sound, and I agree with it wholly.

Paragraph 33 →

Full judgment

VREPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS

CIVIL APPEAL NO. E193 OF 2026

FELIX MUSYOKI MUTUA…………….…..... 1ST APPELLANT/APPLICANT

MARGARET MWETHYA MUTUA ..............2ND APPELLANT/APPLICANT

VERSUS

RUTH BUKA BUKACHI…………………………….......… 1ST RESPONDENT

PATJUD FUNERAL HOME ..........................................2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

Introduction:

1. This ruling is on the Applicants’ Notice of Motion application dated 9th October 2026 seeking for orders that:-

i. Spent.

ii. Spent.

iii. Pending the hearing and determination of the application and the appeal, there be stay of execution and/or enforcement of the judgement and consequential orders delivered on 8th October 2026 in Kangundo MCCC E196 OF 2026.

iv. The application and appeal be heard on an expedited basis.

v. The Applicants abide by such reasonable directions as this honourable Court may impose concerning continued preservation of the body and mortuary charges.

vi. The costs of the application be in the appeal.

2. The application is supported by the supporting affidavit of Margaret Mwethya Mutua, the 2nd Applicant. There are no grounds set out on the face of the application.

3. The application is opposed by Ruth Wanza Bukachi, the 1st Respondent through her Replying Affidavit sworn on 13th October 2026.

4. The 2nd Respondent has not participated in the instant application.

5. The instant application was listed for directions on 15th October 2026 when the Court directed the parties to proceed and make oral submissions.

6. Mr. Munguti, Counsel for the Applicants submitted that the lower court at Kangundo had directed that the deceased be buried at Matetani in Kangundo as opposed to Kawethei also in Kangundo. It was argued that the 2nd Applicant is the surviving widow of the deceased with whom they had lived with from the year 2009 until the time of his demise at Kawethei. It was submitted that the 1st Respondent is a daughter of the deceased who is married of in Vihiga County and has been away up to the date the deceased passed on. It was stated that the Applicants took the deceased to hospital and when he passed on, they placed the body at the 2nd Respondent’s facility. Counsel submitted further that the deceased and the 2nd Applicant are spouses and this establishes the closest relationship thus the appeal is meritorious and arguable. That the deceased had established a home at Kawethei where they stayed since 2009 thus the appeal will be rendered nugatory. It was submitted that the issue involves the burial place of the deceased and once the burial proceeds, it will have irreversible psychological trauma. The balance of convenience will favour having the status quo maintained pending the outcome of the appeal. Counsel stated that the Applicants have undertaken to abide by any conditions for stay including payment of mortuary charges and since this is not a money decree. The issue of deposit of security for costs does not arise. The Applicants asked the court to allow the application.

7. On the other hand, Ms. Kioko Counsel for the 1st Respondent submitted that the 1st Respondent is a biological daughter to the deceased from the first house and her mother (deceased’s first wife) is also deceased. None of the parties has been left out to participate in the burial. Counsel invited the Court to look at the parties’ pleadings more so the Replying Affidavit in making a determination on the application.

Analysis:

8. I have carefully considered the application, the replying affidavit the trial court’s judgement and oral submissions by the Parties’ Advocates. The only issue for my determination is the place of deceased’s burial. Whether I should stay the burial of the deceased herein at Matetani in Kangundo Sub-county as directed by the trial court pending the hearing and determination of this appeal.

9. The background of this matter arises from a burial dispute concerning the late Mathew Mutua Wambua (“deceased”), who died on 4th June 2026 (almost 4 months ago) at the age of approximately 94 years. The deceased’s remains are currently being preserved at the 2nd Respondent’s facility in Nguluni, Matungulu Sub-county, Machakos County since his death.

10. The 1st Respondent, Ruth Wanza Bukachi is a biological daughter of the deceased from his first marriage to the late Ann Mutio Mutua. She instituted suit through a Plaint dated 16th June 2026 at Kangundo law courts in CMCC No. E196 OF 2026 seeking orders to have the deceased buried at his ancestral home in Matetani, Kangundo Sub-county where his first wife is buried. The 1st Respondent’s case is that her parents established their matrimonial home at Matetani, where her mother is buried. She stated that she was very active in her father’s life, regularly sending him money, buying him gifts and ensuring his welfare was attended to. Upon the death of her mother, the deceased started cohabiting with the 2nd Applicant. She acknowledged the 2nd Applicant as her father’s partner but stated that the marriage was never formally solemnized under Kamba Customary Law. The family agreed that it was not proper for the 2nd Applicant to be brought to the 1st Respondent’s mother’s matrimonial home at Matetani, and accordingly, the deceased built the 2nd Applicant a house at his property at Kawethei. The deceased maintained the house at Matetani and visited regularly to ensure it was kept and maintained well. The 1st Respondent stated that the deceased had expressed his wishes through his last Will and Testament dated 22nd October 2025, wherein he directed that he be buried at his ancestral land in Mukunuku village, Matetani. A copy of the Will was produced in evidence. Clause 4.1 and 4.2 of the Will states as follows:-

Clause 4.1-“If I die in the Republic of Kenya, I would want to undergo a normal inexpensive burial at my ancestral land located in Mukunuku village, Matetani, Kangundo location, Machakos County according to the Christian Faith”

Clause 4.2- “That all matters relating to my burial and final rites as regards their administration, finances and all other direction, I direct that my daughter Ruth Wanza Bukachi to take charge, direct and or organize the same to enable me have a proper send off as she took good care of me in my lifetime”.

11. The 1st Respondent stated that after his father died, she, the 2nd Applicant and other family members convened meetings and agreed to bury the deceased at Matetani. A funeral program was prepared, the grave was dug at Matetani, tents were erected and she paid all the mortuary fees at the 2nd Respondent’s facility. However, on the scheduled burial date, the 1st Applicant, who was in possession of the burial permit failed to produce his original identity card at the mortuary and the body of the deceased could not be released. The 1st Respondent felt that the 1st Applicant deliberately frustrated the burial and created chaos at the mortuary, necessitating the intervention of the police hence the institution of this suit.

12. Upon being served with the Plaint and Summons to enter appearance, the Applicants filed a joint Statement of Defence and a Counterclaim opposing the prayers sought in the Plaint and seeking that the deceased be buried at Kawethei. The Applicants stated that the deceased married the 2nd Applicant under Kamba Customary Law in or about the year 2000, and they cohabited continuously as husband and wife until the deceased’s demise.

13. The 1st Applicant, Felix Musyoka Mutua, is the deceased’s son from the relationship with the 2nd Applicant, Margaret Mwethya Mutua. The said 2nd Applicant is the deceased’s surviving partner from a subsequent relationship.

14. The 2nd Applicant stated that in or about 2004, the deceased commenced construction of the matrimonial home at Matetani for the second household but the 1st Respondent and her brothers demolished the house and chased the deceased, the 2nd Applicant and the children of the second household away from Matetani. The Applicants relocated to Kanzia Shopping Centre before establishing a permanent home at Kawethei in 2009, where the deceased resided until his death.

15. The Applicants contend that they were the deceased’s primary care givers during his illness. They produced in evidence medical records, mortuary admission forms and the burial permit issued in the 1st Applicant’s name. They relied on documents recording the deceased’s burial wishes, including two written declarations dated 5th June 2021 and 10th October 2021, in which the deceased stated that he wished to be buried at his home in Kawethei. Thus, the deceased ought to be buried at Kawethei.

16. Upon considering the pleadings, the evidence adduced by both parties and the applicable law, the trial court delivered a judgement on 8th October 2026 in the following terms:-

a) The Plaintiff’s (1st Respondent herein) suit is allowed;

b) The 3rd Defendant’s (2nd Applicant herein) Counterclaim is dismissed.

c) A declaration is hereby issued that the proper and agreed burial site for the deceased, Mathew Mutua Wambua, is at his ancestral land in Mukunuku village, Matetani , Kangundo Sub-county, Machakos County, as directed in his Last Will and Testament dated 22nd October 2025.

d) A permanent injunction is hereby issued restraining the 1st and 3rd Defendants (Applicants herein), their family members, agents and anyone acting on their behalf from burying the deceased anywhere other than Matetani.

e) An order is hereby issued directing the 2nd Defendant /Patjud Funeral Home (2nd Respondent herein) to release the remains of the late Mathew Mutua Wambua to the Plaintiff, Ruth Wanza Bukachi (1st Respondent herein) or her designated agent, for burial at Matetani.

f) The Defendants (Applicants herein) are granted leave to participate in the planning and execution of the burial arrangements, including but not limited to attending funeral planning meetings, contributing ideas and resources, participating in the funeral service and attending the burial at Matetani.

g) The Defendants (Applicants herein) are restrained from interfering with, obstructing or frustrating the burial of the deceased at Matetani, including interfering with the Plaintiff’s (1st Respondent herein) role as the person in charge of the burial as directed in the deceased’s Will.

h) The Officer Commanding Station (OCS), Tala Police Station, is hereby directed to ensure compliance with these orders and to maintain peace during the burial.

i) Each party shall bear its own costs of this suit, this being a family dispute.

17. I have carefully and keenly re-analysed and re-evaluated the evidence adduced before the trial court. There is no dispute that 1st Respondent, Ruth Wanza Bukachi is a biological daughter of the deceased from his first marriage to the late Ann Mutio Mutua (now deceased).

18. There is no dispute that the deceased cohabited with the 2nd Applicant Margaret Mwethya Mutua sometimes in the year 2000 following the demise of his first wife who was the mother to the 1st Respondent. There is no dispute that the deceased had an ancestral land at Matetani village where his first wife was buried and also another land at Kawethei where he resided with the 2nd Applicant up to the time of his demise. Thus, the two homes are built on lands belonging to the deceased, although the respective title deeds or proof of ownership of the same were not produced in evidence.

19. Now turning to the main issue on where the deceased in this case ought to be buried between Matetani village and Kawethei village, I will refer to the case of Peters v Sunday Post Limited [1958] EA 424, where the Court of Appeal for the former Eastern Africa emphasized the restraint with which an appellate court should exercise its power to re-evaluate evidence and interfere with factual findings of the trial court. This principle underscores the deference owed to the trial court's advantage in observing the demeanour and credibility of witnesses.

20. However, it does not absolve the appellate court of its duty to independently evaluate the evidence where necessary, particularly where it is alleged that the trial court erred in law or fact. The court stated:

" It is a strong thing for an appellate court to differ from the findings on a question of fact, of the judge who had the advantage of seeing and hearing the witnesses...But the jurisdiction to review the evidence should be exercised with caution: it is not enough that the appellate court might have come to a different conclusion..."

21. The 1st Respondent relies on the deceased’s Last Will and Testament dated 22nd October 2025 whose relevant Clauses to this matter have been reproduced verbatim hereinabove. The deceased wished to be buried at Matetani Village. The Applicants on the other hand relied on two written declarations dated 5th June 2021 and 10th October 2021, in which the deceased stated that he wished to be buried at his home in Kawethei.

22. On the foregoing, the burden was on both the Applicants and the 1st Respondent to prove their respective cases. This is on the basis of Sections 107-109 of the Evidence Act Cap 80 Laws of Kenya, which provides that:

Section 107-Whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist.

(1) When a person is bound to prove the existence of any fact it is said that the burden of proof lies on that person.

Section 108-The burden of proof in a suit or proceeding lies on that person who would fail if no evidence at all were given on either side.

Section 109-The burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on the person who wishes the court to believe in its existence, unless it is provided by any law that the proof of that fact shall lie on any particular person.

23. Courts have held that the resolution of burial disputes in Kenya is governed by a combination of customary law, common law, and statutory provisions, with African customary law playing a pivotal role as provided under Section 3(2) of the Judicature Act, Cap 8, which states:

“The High Court, the Court of Appeal and all subordinate courts shall be guided by African customary law in civil cases in which one or more of the parties is subject to it or affected by it, so far as it is applicable and is not repugnant to justice and morality or inconsistent with any written law, and shall decide all such cases according to substantial justice without undue regard to technicalities of procedure and without undue delay.”

24. The Court of Appeal in Ontweka & 3 Others v Ondieki (Civil Appeal E692 of 2023) [2024] KECA 11 (KLR) (25 January 2024) (Judgment) held that:

“…burial disputes are emotive, and the court is called upon to balance the clashing interests of parties who should ordinarily be involved in the burial in one way or another. Unlike many other civil disputes, burial issues concern people who are close to the deceased in one way or the other. Consequently, this court desires to find some sense of legal and constitutional harmony by overcoming the dichotomies that seem to make burial dispute jurisprudence disarrayed. As stated by Allan Kellehear in ‘Grief and Loss: Past, Present and Future’ (2002) 177 Medical Journal of Australia 177, physical, spiritual and intellectual experiences of grief and bereavement cannot be understood in isolation, but only in the context of social norms, personal styles and cultural prescriptions.”

25. The court proceeded to state that:

“43. In burial disputes, we can only call our Constitution a living Constitution if it also considers the customs that communities regard as crucial in death rites but only to the extent that the death rites also promote constitutionalism. In the same breath, we can only call our customary practices progressive customs if they promote the burial wishes of the deceased that do not flout constitutional order.”

26. While it is trite that there is no property in a dead body, it is crucial that the wishes of the deceased as regards the manner of his interment ought to be considered. In this case, the deceased’s Last Will and Testament dated 22nd October 2025 was admitted in evidence, the deceased expressed clear wishes regarding his burial that in the event he died in the Republic of Kenya, he would wish to be buried at his ancestral land located in Mukunuku village, Matetani, Kangundo Location, Machakos County.

27. In addition, this Court takes note that the written declarations dated 5th June 2021 and 10th October 2021 relied upon by the Applicants were allegedly made in the year 2021 whereas the deceased’s Last Will and Testament was made on 22nd October 2025, four years later. The deceased’s Will thus ranks first in priority and it overrides the prior declarations.

28. The evidence shows that the deceased left a valid Will. With such compelling evidence, the Court cannot go against the wishes of the deceased. I rely on the case of Onindo Wambi -vs- COO & Another (2015) KЕСА 620 (KLR).

29. Based on the above, the issue as to whether the 2nd Applicant was married or not married to the deceased under Kamba Customary Law is neither here nor there. The Court ought to give effect to the wishes of the deceased as far as possible.

30. Clearly, the evidence presented by the 1st Respondent showcased how the deceased expressed his wishes to be buried and how the wishes were to be executed. The Deceased Person had his Last Will and Testament and it is in the interest of justice that the last wishes and testament of the deceased are fulfilled.

31. The Applicants did not adduce any evidence to controvert the 1st Respondent’s case on the evidence the 1st Respondent placed before the trial court.

Disposition

32. In the end, I find that the trial court rightly considered the Parties’ respective cases and the evidence in support thereof and rightly found that the 1st Respondent had proven the deceased’s wish to be buried at his ancestral land in Mukunuku village, Matetani, Kangundo Sub-county, Machakos County as directed in his Last Will and Testament dated 22nd October 2025 which qualifies the required standard under the doctrine of the deceased’s wishes. For almost four (4) months now, the deceased’s remains have been at the mortuary and it is a high time that he should be buried and have his soul rest in eternal peace. I echo the emphasis of the trial court that it is a time for the family to come together and honour their patriarch.

33. In the circumstances, it is my finding that the judgment of the trial court is sound, and I agree with it wholly.

34. The upshot is that the Applicants’ Notice of Motion dated 9th October 2026 is found to be without merit and the same is dismissed. The judgement of the trial court delivered on 8th October 2026 is upheld.

35. Following the dismissal of the application as ordered above, there is nothing left to be determined in the appeal wherefore the appeal too is hereby dismissed in its entirety. Any issue touching on the deceased and his estate may be raised in the deceased’s main Succession Cause.

36. There shalI be no order as to costs since this is a family matter save that the Applicants will settle any accrued mortuary charges at the 2nd Respondent’s facility in respect of the deceased herein as ordered by this court on 15th October 2026.

37. It is hereby so ordered. The file is closed.

RULING DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED ON VIRTUAL TEAMS AT MACHAKOS THIS 22ND OCTOBER 2026

NOEL I. ADAGI

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder