General

Mua v Mongare & 9 others [2026] KEHC 17455 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Case number
Commercial Cause No. E001 of 2026
Judgment date
26 October 2026
Judge(s)
Noel I. Adagi

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling is on two notices of Preliminary Objections. The first is by the 1st Defendant/Applicant- Kwamboka Joy Mongare dated 30th January 2026 raised on the Plaintiff/Respondent’s Originating Summons dated 14th January 2026 since the same as filed and presented before this Honourable court is fatally defective and bad in law ab initio on the following grounds namely:-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have carefully considered the preliminary objections herein raised by the 1st and 2nd Defendants/Applicants, the response thereto by the Plaintiff/Respondent, the parties’ rival submissions and the relevant provisions of Order 52 of the civil procedure rules and Section 57 of the Advocates Act upon which the objections are respectively premised. The only issue for my determination is whether the preliminary objections herein are…

Paragraph 5 →

Reasoning passage

This court finds that the 1st Defendant’s preliminary objection dated 30th January 2026 does not raise a pure point of law as the court is being invited to establish whether or not there existed any oral or written undertaking and or a retainer between the 1st Defendant and the Plaintiff herein which will be going into matters of evidence. Accordingly, the preliminary objection dated 30th January 2026 is found to be without merit and…

Paragraph 14 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS COMMERCIAL CAUSE NO. E001 OF 2026

JOSEPHAT MUSYOKA MUA ...........................PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT

-VERSUS-

KWAMBOKA JOY MONGARE....................1ST DEFENDANT/APPLCANT

PAUL LOKI TUNGA..................................2ND DEFENDANT/APPLICANT

DOUGLAS MUTUA MUUMBI.........................................3RD DEFENDANT

MOSES KAMOLO ......................................PROPOSED 4TH DEFENDANT

BENJAMIN KYALO KARANJA ....................PROPOSED 5TH DEFENDANT

BRYAN OPWAKA .. ..................................PROPOSED 6TH DEFENDANT

ANITAH MASAKI (MORAA) .. ....................PROPOSED 7TH DEFENDANT

DAVID MANYOLO ................................... PROPOSED 8TH DEFENDANT

FAITH MBULA KAINDI .............................. PROPOSED 9TH DEFENDANT

DENNIS KILONZI JAMES ..........................PROPOSED 10TH DEFENDANT

RULING

Introduction

1. This ruling is on two notices of Preliminary Objections. The first is by the 1st Defendant/Applicant- Kwamboka Joy Mongare dated 30th January 2026 raised on the Plaintiff/Respondent’s Originating Summons dated 14th January 2026 since the same as filed and presented before this Honourable court is fatally defective and bad in law ab initio on the following grounds namely:-

1. The suit is a nullity for want of originating pleadings. The court can only be approached through a plaint in the present circumstances as Order 52 of the Civil Procedure Rules is only applicable to a scenario where a professional undertaking exists. The 1st Defendant herein never issued a professional undertaking to the Plaintiff herein and therefore the Plaintiff cannot take out originating summons for determination of the claim for compensation and/or breach of contract.

2. The 1st Defendant disputes the existence of any oral or written undertaking and therefore where there is a question as to the existence of the undertaking, the plaintiff cannot take out originating summons.

3. That in light of the above, the suit before the court is incompetent and the 1st Defendant humbly prays that the originating summons be struck out with costs.

2. The second notice of preliminary objection is dated 15th April 2026 filed by the 2nd Defendant/ Applicant- Paul Loki Tunga objecting to the hearing of this suit on grounds that:

l. The Pleadings do not reveal any cause of action nor does it seek any prayers that can be acted upon by the honourable court.

2. Disputes between client and advocates are a preserve of the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal (ADT) established under Section 57 of the Advocates Act.

3. The High court can only sit on appeals on decisions from the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal (ADT)

3. The above two preliminary objections were filed following the institution of this suit by the Plaintiff vide Originating Summons dated 14th January 2026. What I can distil from the Originating Summons herein is that the Plaintiff/Respondent appears to be making very serious allegations of breach of retainer agreements, unlawful termination of provision of legal services, coercion, extortion, fraud, abuse of process of court, corruption, obstruction of justice and tortious interference against the Defendants/ Applicants and the rest of the Defendants who are Advocates of the High Court of Kenya.

Directions

4. The two preliminary objections herein came up for directions on 13/5/2026 and the court directed both preliminary objections to be heard together. The affected Parties were then directed to file and exchange their respective submissions to which they complied.

Analysis and determination

5. I have carefully considered the preliminary objections herein raised by the 1st and 2nd Defendants/Applicants, the response thereto by the Plaintiff/Respondent, the parties’ rival submissions and the relevant provisions of Order 52 of the civil procedure rules and Section 57 of the Advocates Act upon which the objections are respectively premised. The only issue for my determination is whether the preliminary objections herein are merited.

6. A Preliminary Objection is defined in the famous case of Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd vs Westend Distributors Ltd [1969] E.A. 696 where the court observed that:

“…a ‘preliminary objection’ consists of a point of law which has been pleaded, or which arises by clear implication out of pleadings, and which if argued as a preliminary point may dispose of the suit. Examples are an objection to the jurisdiction of the court or a plea of limitation or a submission that the parties are bound by the contract giving rise to the suit to refer the dispute to arbitration.”

Sir Charles Newbold P. added as follows at page 701:

“ A preliminary objection is in the nature of what used to be a demurrer. It raises a pure point of law which is argued on the assumption that all the facts pleaded by the other side are correct. It cannot be raised if any fact has to be ascertained or if what is sought is the exercise of judicial discretion.”

7. I am duly guided by the foregoing and I do not see any reason to depart from the same. It follows therefore, that I shall base my findings on pure questions of law as regards jurisdiction of this Court as raised in the preliminary objection.

Preliminary Objection dated 30th January 2026

8. The gravamen of the 1st Defendant’s objection is that the Plaintiff/Respondent’s Originating Summons dated 14/1/2026 as filed and presented before this Honourable court is fatally defective and bad in law ab initio on the ground that this court can only be approached through a plaint in the present circumstances as Order 52 of the Civil Procedure Rules is only applicable to a scenario where a professional undertaking exists. The 1st Defendant herein never issued a professional undertaking to the Plaintiff herein and therefore the Plaintiff cannot take out originating summons for determination of the claim for compensation and/or breach of contract.

9. Order 52 Rule 71 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides for an application for order for enforcement of an undertaking and states that:

(1) An application for an order for the enforcement of an undertaking given by an advocate shall be made—

(a)if the undertaking was given in a suit in the High Court, by summons in chambers in that suit; or

(b)in any other case, by originating summons in the High Court.

(2) Save for special reasons to be recorded by the judge, the order shall in the first instance be that the advocate shall honour his undertaking within a time fixed by the order, and only thereafter may an order in enforcement be made.

10. The above provision requires that the plaintiff provides sufficient proof of the existence of a professional undertaking. A professional undertaking is enforceable in the same manner as a contract when there is breach. A professional undertaking is enforceable against the Advocate personally and therefore the Advocate must exercise care when giving and accepting an undertaking, Care requires that the Advocate observes the following principles in giving an undertaking.

11. The 1st Defendant argues that the Plaintiff has not provided sufficient proof of the existence of any oral or written undertaking and a retainer if any that constitute an undertaking as envisaged in Order 52 Rule 71of the Civil Procedure Rules.

12. Basically, what the 1st Defendant is contesting is the fact that the Plaintiff has not provided evidence on existence of any oral or written undertaking and or a retainer. This court is of the considered view that the Plaintiff can only do so at the hearing of the suit where he would be expected to prove the facts pleaded in his suit through adduction of evidence.

13. Where the facts giving rise to jurisdiction are contested, the Court cannot determine the issue summarily particularly through a preliminary objection. This position was affirmed in Avtar Singh Bhamra & Another v Oriental Commercial Bank [2023] KEHC, where the Court held:

“Where the issue of jurisdiction depends on contested facts, the court must allow parties to adduce evidence rather than determine the matter summarily.”

14. This court finds that the 1st Defendant’s preliminary objection dated 30th January 2026 does not raise a pure point of law as the court is being invited to establish whether or not there existed any oral or written undertaking and or a retainer between the 1st Defendant and the Plaintiff herein which will be going into matters of evidence. Accordingly, the preliminary objection dated 30th January 2026 is found to be without merit and is dismissed.

Preliminary Objection dated 15th April 2026

15. On the second preliminary objection, the 2nd Defendant contends that the pleadings do not reveal any cause of action nor does it seek any prayers that can be acted upon by the honourable court. Disputes between client and advocates are a preserve of the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal established under Section 57 of the Advocates Act hence the High court can only sit on appeals on decisions from the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal.

16. Section 57 of the Advocates Act Cap 16 of the laws of Kenya establishes a tribunal known as the Disciplinary Tribunal which handles complaints against Advocates.

17. The Preliminary Objection by the 2nd Defendant is to the effect that Advocate-Client disputes are a preserve of the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal established under Section 57 of the Advocates Act.

18. Section 60 of the Advocates Act provides how complaints against advocates are handled in the tribunal.

Section 60(1) states that:-

“A complaint against an advocate of professional misconduct, which expression includes disgraceful or dishonourable conduct incompatible with the status of an advocate, may be made to the Tribunal by any person”.

19. As earlier stated, the Plaintiff/Respondent appears to be making very serious allegations of breach of retainer agreements, unlawful termination of provision of legal services, coercion, extortion, fraud, abuse of process of court, corruption, obstruction of justice and tortious interference against the Defendants/Applicants and the rest of the Defendants who are Advocates of the High Court of Kenya in his Originating Summons dated 14th January 2026.

20. The Plaintiff has not disclosed in his Originating Summons herein whether he ever made complaints at the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal against the named Defendants who are Advocates of the High Court of Kenya.

21. The High Court can only sit on appeals on the decisions of the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal. There is no evidence of any decision by the tribunal which is capable of being appealed or has been appealed to this Court. This Court agrees that the first place the Plaintiff can present the very serious allegations he has raised against the Defendants (Advocates) in the Originating Summons is the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal. Until he does so and a decision is made by the Tribunal, this court has no jurisdiction to hear, entertain and determine the Plaintiff’s suit filed vide the Originating Summons herein.

Disposition

22. In view of my analysis herein above, it is my finding that:

a. The preliminary objection dated 30th January 2026 filed by the 1st Defendant/Applicant – Kwamboka Joy Mongare is found to be without merit and is dismissed with no order as to costs.

b. The preliminary objection dated 15th April 2026 filed by the 2nd Defendant/ Applicant- Paul Loki Tunga is found to have merit and the same is allowed with costs assessed at Kshs.20,000/=.

c. The Originating Summons dated 14th January 2026 is hereby dismissed in its entirety with costs assessed at Kshs.30,000 payable to each of the Defendant who has so far filed and served a response to it.

d. This file is closed. Orders accordingly

RULING DATED & SIGNED & DELIVERED AT MACHAKOS THIS 26TH OCTOBER 2026

NOEL I. ADAGI

JUDGE

DELIVERED VIRTUALLY ON TEAMS AT MACHAKOS THIS 26TH OCTOBER 2026

In the presence of :

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder