REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS
CIVIL DIVISION (APPELLATE SIDE)
CIVIL APPEAL NO. E247 OF 2024
BETWEEN
COSMAS KILONZO DAUDI….………...................................................APPELLANT
AND
CHINA WU YI COMPANY………………….………………………..RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal from the Judgement and Decree of Hon. E.K. Suter, PM dated 12th September 2024 at the Magistrates Court at Machakos in CMCC No. 65B of 2018)
JUDGMENT
Introduction and Background
1. In the subordinate court, the Appellant filed suit claiming that he was employed by the Respondent and that on or about 9th September 2017, while working at the Respondent’s premises, he was provided with an unsafe system of work and a metal bar fell on him, causing him serious injuries. The Appellant averred that the accident was caused by the Respondent’s negligence, including failure to take adequate safety precautions, failing to provide a safe working system, failing to provide protective devices and failing to provide adequate supervision. He stated that he sustained a deep cut wound on the occipital region, pain and blood loss and he sought general damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenities, special damages of Kshs.3,000.00, costs and interest.
2. In its defence, the Respondent denied most of the allegations including that the Appellant was its employee and put him to strict proof of the employment relationship and the alleged period of employment. The Respondent denied any negligence on its part or breach of duty/contract stating the claims were fabrications and thus prayed that the suit be dismissed with costs. At the hearing, the Appellant testified as the sole witness and the Respondent did not call any witnesses or participate in the trial, despite being served.
3. The subordinate court rendered a judgment on 12th September 2024 where it noted that in a work injury claim, the employer-employee relationship must be proved. The Learned Magistrate found that the Appellant failed to produce any document supporting his engagement such as a payslip, contract, or letter and that he did not call a co-worker to attest to his employment and did not testify on how or when he was employed. Consequently, the subordinate court found there was no proof of an employment relationship, which is central to establishing liability. On quantum, the subordinate court held that had liability been proven, it would have awarded Kshs.150,000.00 for general damages based on comparable soft tissue injury cases and Ksh.3,000.00 for special damages. In sum, the Appellant’s case was dismissed for failing to prove his case on a balance of probabilities and each party was ordered to bear its own costs.
4. Dissatisfied with this finding, the Appellant has appealed to the court through his Memorandum of Appeal dated 16th September 2024. He avers that the Learned Magistrate misdirected herself in finding that the Appellant had not adduced any evidence to the effect that there was an employee-employer relationship with the Respondent and that the Appellant had not discharged the burden of proof to warrant liability being assessed at 100% in his favor. That the trial court erred in its findings on liability, yet the Appellant had adduced sufficient evidence to support his case and that it erred by dismissing the Appellant's case, yet he had tendered overwhelming evidence to support his case. As such, the Appellant prays that the trial court's findings on liability be set aside/reviewed, the appeal be allowed and the costs of the appeal be borne by the Respondent.
5. The court directed that the appeal be canvassed by way of written submissions but only those of the Appellant are on record as the Respondent did not participate in this appeal despite service.
Analysis and Determination
6. As submitted by the Appellant, this being a first appeal, the court is not bound to follow the subordinate court’s findings of fact if it appears either that it failed to take account of particular circumstances or probabilities and that this court’s mandate is to reappraise the material availed to the court below and to draw its own conclusions on the facts emerging from the material (see Selle and Another v Associated Motor Boat Company Ltd. and Others [1968] EA 123 and Peters v Sunday Post Limited [1958] EA 424).
7. The Appellant submits that this appeal raises only one issue; whether the Learned Magistrate erred in finding that the Respondent had not proved that he was an employee of the Appellant. It is not lost to me that the applicable law as to the burden of proof is found in sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act(Chapter 80 of the Laws of Kenya). The Court of Appeal in Mumbi M'Nabea v David M.Wachira [2016] KECA 773 (KLR), while discussing the standard of proof in civil liability claims in our jurisdiction had this to say:
“In our jurisdiction, the standard of proof in civil liability claims is that of the balance of probabilities. This means that the Court will assess the oral, documentary and real evidence advanced by each party and decide which case is more probable. To put it another way, on the evidence, which occurrence of the event was more likely to happen than not. Section 107(1) of the Evidence Act, Cap 80 Laws of Kenya provides as follows:-
“Whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist.”
The above provision provides for the legal burden of proof. However, Section 109 of the same Act provides for the evidentiary burden of proof and states as follows:-
“The burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on the person who wishes the court to believe in its existence, unless it is provided by any law that the proof of that fact shall lie on any particular person.”
The position was re-affirmed by the Court of Appeal in Maria Ciabaitaru M’mairanyi & others v Blue Shield Insurance Company Limited -Civil Appeal No. 101 of 2000 [2005] 1 EA 280 where it was held that:-
“Whereas under section 107 of the Evidence Act, (which deals with the evidentiary burden of proof), the burden of proof lies upon the party who invokes the aid of the law and substantially asserts the affirmative of the issue, section 109 of the same Act recognises that the burden of proof as to any particular fact may be cast on the person who wishes the Court to believe in its existence.”
8. Having gone through the record and the Appellant’s submissions, I am unable to find fault in the subordinate court’s findings because the same were based on a complete lack of foundational evidence, not just a lack of documents. As stated, the trial court noted that the Appellant did not testify on how and when he was employed and on the terms of such employment, he did not call any co-worker or supervisor to corroborate his claim that he worked for the Respondent and he failed to produce any supporting documentation such as payslips, job cards, or letters to prove his employment.
9. The Appellant submits that under section 10(7) of the Employment Act (Chapter 226 of the Laws of Kenya), the burden shifts to the employer if they fail to produce a written contract. However, this is a misinterpretation of the law because the burden only shifts after the employee has adduced some evidence to establish the existence of an oral or implied contract. As cited in the Appellant's own authorities including Casmir Nyankuru Nyaberi v Mwakikar Agencies Limited [2016] KEELRC 1323 (KLR), "Even where an employment contract is oral in nature, the Claimant must still adduce some evidence whether documentary or viva voce to corroborate their word." The Appellant failed to meet this initial threshold.
10. The Appellant has also relied on the fact that the Respondent did not enter an appearance or call witnesses, meaning his testimony was uncontroverted. While it is true that the trial court must consider this, it should not be lost that in such circumstances, a plaintiff still had a duty to prove its case on a balance of probabilities as is required by law. This was held by the Court of Appeal in Karugi & another v Kabiya & 3 others [1983] KECA 38 (KLR) where it was stated that, “The burden was always on the Plaintiff to prove his case on a balance of probabilities even if the case was heard as formal proof”. Likewise, failure by a defendant to contest the case does not absolve a plaintiff of the duty to prove the case to the required standard hence in Gichinga Kibutha v Caroline Nduku [2018] KEELC 3981 (KLR) the court held that, “It is not automatic that instances where the evidence is not controverted the Claimants shall have his way in Court. He must discharge the burden of proof. He must prove his case however much the opponent has not made a presence in the contest.”
11. Therefore, uncontroverted evidence must still be sufficient and credible enough to meet the balance of probabilities. A mere assertion of employment without any details regarding the nature of the work, the duration, the payment arrangement, or any corroboration, is too vague to discharge the burden of proof.
12. The Appellant further submits that the trial court selectively analyzed the evidence, however, my perusal of the record shows the trial court correctly applied the binding principles laid out in West Kenya Sugar Company Limited v Bushuru [2023] KEELRC 549 (KLR) that the determination of an employer-employee relationship is central to a work injury claim. By failing to provide even the most basic oral evidence of the employment terms, the Appellant left the court with no basis to infer that an employment relationship existed.
13. In the end, I find that the Learned Magistrate applied the correct civil standard and found that a mere oral assertion of employment, devoid of any details or corroboration, did not tip the scales in the Appellant's favor. The trial court's conclusion that the employment relationship was not proved is sound, supported by the record and in line with established legal principles.
Conclusion and Disposition
14. The upshot is that the appeal stands dismissed but with no order as to costs.
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED virtually this 26th DAY OF OCTOBER
2026
............................................................................
J W W MONGARE
JUDGE
In the presence of;
1. N/A for the Appellant
2. N/A for the Respondent
3. Abdisalan- Court Assistant