Civil law

Teua Self-Help Group (Suing through the Chairman, Secretary & Treasurer) v Mwalimu [2026] KEHC 16947 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Case number
Civil Appeal E074 of 2026
Judgment date
27 October 2026
Judge(s)
J W W Mongare

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Appellant, through the Notice of Motion dated 15th May 2026 seeks to stay of execution of the Ruling delivered on 11th May 2026 and a stay of proceedings in Mavoko MCCC No. E583 of 2025; Peter Kaleso Mwalimu v Equity Bank and Teua Youth Group pending the hearing and determination of the appeal. The application is supported by the grounds on its face and the supporting affidavit of the Appellant’s Chairman Hericson Mutisya Mukilya…

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS

CIVIL DIVISION (APPELLATE SIDE)

CIVIL APPEAL NO.E074 OF 2026

BETWEEN

TEUA SELF-HELP GROUP

(suing through the Chairman, Secretary & Treasurer)..............................APPELLANT

AND

PETER KALESO MWALIMU…………….………………………….…RESPONDENT

RULING

Introduction & Background

1. The Appellant, through the Notice of Motion dated 15th May 2026 seeks to stay of execution of the Ruling delivered on 11th May 2026 and a stay of proceedings in Mavoko MCCC No. E583 of 2025; Peter Kaleso Mwalimu v Equity Bank and Teua Youth Group pending the hearing and determination of the appeal. The application is supported by the grounds on its face and the supporting affidavit of the Appellant’s Chairman Hericson Mutisya Mukilya sworn on 15th May 2026. The Respondent opposes the application through his replying affidavit sworn on 18th June 2026. The parties have also supplemented their arguments by filing written submissions which I have considered and I will be making relevant references to the same in my analysis and determination below.

Analysis and Determination

2. Upon careful consideration of the pleadings and the rival submissions filed by the parties, I note that the issue that arises for determination is whether the Appellants have established a valid basis for this court to grant an order for stay of execution and stay of proceedings. As submitted by the parties, the legal framework for granting a stay of execution pending appeal is well settled under Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Appellant must demonstrate that they will suffer substantial loss if the order is not granted, that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and that they are willing to provide such security as the court may order for the due performance of the decree.

3. The Appellant rightly submits that these principles were enunciated in Butt v Rent Restriction Tribunal [1979] KECA 22 (KLR) where the Court of Appeal stated what ought to be considered in determining whether to grant or refuse stay of execution pending appeal. The court said that:-

1. The power of the court to grant or refuse an application for a stay of execution is discretionary; and the discretion should be exercised in such a way as not to prevent an appeal.

2. Secondly, the general principle in granting or refusing a stay is, if there is no other overwhelming hindrance, a stay must be granted so that an appeal may not be rendered nugatory should the appeal court reverse the judge’s discretion.

3. Thirdly, a judge should not refuse a stay if there are good grounds for granting it merely because, in his opinion, a better remedy may become available to the applicant at the end of the proceedings.

4. Finally, the Court in exercising its discretion whether to grant or refuse an application for stay will consider the special circumstances and its unique requirements. The court in exercising its powers under Order XLI Rule 4(2) (b) of the Civil Procedure Rules, can order security upon application by either party or on its own motion. Failure to put security of costs as ordered will cause the order for stay of execution to lapse.

4. On stay of proceedings, this is governed by broader judicial discretion and is exercised sparingly. This court has laid out various principles that guide its determination of an application to stay proceedings and I am persuaded by a 3-judge bench ruling of this court in William Odhiambo Ramogi v Attorney General and three others 2019 eKLR where five guiding principles were set out as follows:

1. There must be a pending Appeal.

2. The application must be made expeditiously.

3. The Appeal must risk being rendered nugatory.

4. Exceptional circumstances must exist.

5. The prejudice must be irreparable or incapable of being compensated by damages.

5. All these factors must be considered for an order of stay of proceedings to be granted. Halsbury’s Laws of England, 4th Ed. Vol. 37 (Practice and Procedure) at p.330 states that “The stay of proceedings is a serious, grave and fundamental interruption in the right that a party has to conduct his litigation towards the trial on the basis of the substantive merits of his case, and therefore the Court’s general practice is that a stay of proceedings should not be imposed unless the proceedings, beyond reasonable doubt, ought not to be allowed to continue….This is a power which, it has been emphasized, ought to be exercised sparingly, and only in exceptional cases…It will be exercised where the proceedings are shown to be frivolous, vexatious or harassing or to be manifestly groundless or in which there is clearly no cause of action in law or in equity. The Applicant for a stay on this ground must show not merely that the Plaintiff might not, or probably would not, succeed but that he could not possibly succeed on the basis of the pleading and the facts of this case.” (see Sigat v Sigat [2025] KEELC 5808 (KLR)]

6. The Appellant states that the Respondent moved the subordinate court under a Certificate of Urgency and a Notice of Motion dated 19th January 2026, seeking orders compelling the Appellant to return a birth certificate in the name of FT (a minor) and a cash sum of Kshs. 165,700.00. The subordinate court delivered a Ruling on 11th May 2026, ordering the Appellant to return the claimed birth certificate within seven (7) days, failing which the Respondent would be at liberty to apply for further orders. The Appellant was also ordered to pay costs of Kshs. 15,000.00.

7. The Appellant contends that the subordinate court erred by disregarding their deposition in response and the rules of evidence, that no evidence was presented to prove the birth certificate was ever inside the repossessed motor vehicle or in the Appellant's possession, that the Respondent's claim was an afterthought, brought more than six months after the motor vehicle was repossessed on 16th April 2025 and the O.B. was taken on 16th May 2025. They also fault the impugned orders as being ambiguous and prejudicial, particularly the provision allowing the Respondent to apply for "such further orders as may be necessary."

8. The Appellant avers that the Respondent has already commenced enforcement by demanding compliance via email, despite being informed repeatedly that the birth certificate is not in the Appellant's custody. That they are incapable of complying with the orders and unless stay is granted, the Respondent may commence execution proceedings, rendering the appeal nugatory. They also contend that the application has been brought without unreasonable delay and it is in the interest of justice that the orders sought be granted.

9. In response, the Respondent depones that the Appellant has failed to demonstrate the substantial loss they would suffer if stay is not granted, as required under Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules. That the application is brought in bad faith, intended to waste the Court's time, abuse the court process and deny the Respondent the fruits of the subordinate court's ruling which he contends was well-reasoned and not erroneous.

10. The Respondent states that the Appellant did not demonstrate any legal authority to legitimize the repossession of the Respondent's motor vehicle and he characterizes the repossession as theft and a violation of his right to property under Article 40 of the Constitution. He asserts that at the time of the unlawful repossession, the Respondent's minor daughter's birth certificate was inside the motor vehicle and that this certificate was needed for the child's medical attention, and the subordinate court rightly ordered its return. That the Appellant failed to provide an inventory of the items recovered from the motor vehicle at the time of repossession, he has refused to return the items, frustrating the Respondent to the point of lodging a complaint at Mlolongo Police Station through OB No. 21/16/05/2025.

11. The Respondent depones that the application is solely intended to deny the Respondent the fruits of the subordinate court's ruling and that it is in the interest of justice, fairness and equity that the application be dismissed with costs.

12. Having gone through the pleadings and submissions, I do not think it is in dispute that the application was filed without unreasonable delay as it was filed within 4 days of the ruling. On substantial loss, Judgment was delivered on 24th October 2025, the subordinate court granted a 30-day stay expiring on 23rd November 2025 and this application was filed on 21st November 2025 before the stay expired which is clearly within time and without any delay.

13. On substantial loss, the Appellant has stated that the Respondent's financial status is unknown and that it fears the Respondent cannot refund the Kshs. 15,000.00 if the appeal succeeds. As submitted by the Respondent, the Court of Appeal in Kenya Shell Limited v Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & another [1986] KECA 94 (KLR), Platt Ag JA., observed that substantial loss may arise in two circumstances; where payment of the decretal sum would cause difficulty to the applicant; or where the respondent would be unable to repay the decretal sum if the appeal succeeds. In Kenya Orient Insurance Co Ltd v Paul Mathenge Gichuki & another [2014] KEHC 5311 (KLR), this court (Kasango J.,) held that the burden of proof that the Respondent can refund the decretal sum if the appeal succeeds, shifts to the Respondent the moment Appellant states that it is unaware of Respondent’s resources. This position was affirmed by the Court of Appeal in various decisions including Kenya Commercial Bank Limited v Robert Kimutai Korir [2018] KECA 861 (KLR) where it was held that “Once an applicant has, on reasonable grounds, stated that a respondent has no ability to repay an amount of money in dispute or stated that the respondent’s financial status is unknown, the evidential burden shifts to the respondent to show that he is a person of means and that he would be in a position to refund the money if it is paid out to him and the appeal succeeds.”

14. In this case, I find that this is a money decree of only Kshs. 15,000.00, which is relatively modest and the appellate court in Kenya Shell (supra)  noted that where a case involves a money decree capable of being repaid, refusal of stay would not render the appeal nugatory. However, the more significant issue is the mandatory order to return the birth certificate. The Appellant claims it does not have the certificate and is therefore incapable of compliance. I am in agreement with the Appellant that if execution proceeds, the Appellant may be cited for contempt, which could lead to imprisonment. I find that this would be a substantial loss that goes beyond monetary compensation.

15. On security, the Appellant has not expressly offered security in their pleadings or submissions. It should not be lost that the conditions under Order 42 Rule 6(2)(a) and (b) are cumulative and all must be satisfied (see Trust Bank Limited v Ajay Shah & 3 Others [2012] KEHC 3092 (KLR) . However, courts have discretion to grant stay subject to security and I will therefore allow the stay on condition that the Appellant deposits security of Kshs. 15,000.00.

16. On stay of proceedings, as stated, the bar is higher than that of a stay of execution as the Appellant is required to show the subordinate court proceedings could not possibly succeed. Whereas I can agree with the Appellant that the appeal might be rendered nugatory if the subordinate court proceeds on the basis of the impugned Ruling, I find that the Appellant has not demonstrated that the Respondent's case could not possibly succeed. On the contrary, the subordinate court found the repossession was unlawful, a finding the Appellant disputes but has not shown to be impossible and that the Respondent had provided detailed evidence of the photograph of the minor, Biochemistry Report and police OB while the Appellant's denial was general and lacked specific evidentiary support. The subordinate court explicitly held the Appellant bore the evidentiary burden to show the vehicle was empty at repossession and failed to discharge it. The Appellant's argument is essentially that the subordinate court erred but not that the Respondent's claim is manifestly groundless or impossible to succeed. 

17. Further, the Appellant's circumstances of the alleged inability to comply with a mandatory order and ambiguity in the Ruling are serious, but courts have been reluctant to find "exceptional circumstances" merely because a party disagrees with a subordinate court's finding. The fact that the Appellant claims it never had the birth certificate is a merits argument and it is precisely the kind of issue the appeal itself is to resolve, not a reason to halt all subordinate court proceedings. I also find that the Kshs. 15,000.00 awarded as costs are clearly compensable by damages and this does not support stay of proceedings. The birth certificate issue is not a money matter, but the Appellant's position is that it does not have the certificate. If true, the Appellant suffers no direct prejudice from the order per se as the prejudice arises from the risk of contempt, which is a procedural consequence that could be addressed by the subordinate court or by the appeal itself.

18. I note that the Appellant cites the decision of the court (Meoli J.,) in David Macharia Gitonga v Joyce Wanjiku Macharia [2020] KEHC 2265 (KLR) but I find this case to be distinguishable as the Appellant had already been cited for contempt and the matter was set for hearing and the risk was imminent and concrete. In this case, the Appellant fears future contempt proceedings, but no contempt application has yet been filed and the threat is anticipatory and not actual. In summary therefore, it is my finding that the Appellant has failed to surmount the high and stringent test for a stay of proceedings.

Disposition

19. The upshot is that a stay of execution of the ruling of the subordinate court dated 11th May 2026 is granted on condition that the Appellant shall within 15 (fifteen) days from the date of this ruling deposit the sum of Kshs. 15,000.00 in court failing which the stay shall lapse automatically and the Respondent shall be at liberty to execute. Costs of this application shall be in the cause.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED virtually this 27th DAY OF OCTOBER

2026

............................................................................

J W W MONGARE

JUDGE

In the presence of;

1. Mr. Kipruto holding brief for Ms. Waithera for the Appellant

2. N/A for the Respondent

3. Abdisalan- Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder