General

Techno Relief Services Limited v County Government of Machakos [2026] KEHC 16945 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Case number
COMM. CASE NO. E003 OF 2020
Judgment date
27 October 2026
Judge(s)
J W W Mongare

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Defendant has filed two applications dated 20th December 2023 and 9th July 2024 seeking to set aside the ex parte proceedings of 18th October 2023, reopen the case for a de novo hearing on a priority basis and that the court allows it to participate by recalling the Plaintiff's witness for cross-examination and defending the suit. The Defendant also seeks to review, set aside, and/or vacate the ex parte judgment of 19th June 2024.…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Upon careful consideration of the pleadings and the submissions filed by the parties I note that the primary issue for determination is whether the court ought to review and set aside the ex parte proceedings of 18th October 2023 and the consequent judgment of 19th June 2024. I note that the Defendants’ applications are grounded under inter alia Order 10 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules which empowers the court to set aside or vary…

Paragraph 2 →

Reasoning passage

Having gone through the pleadings and submissions, I am inclined to agree with the Plaintiff that the Defendant’s explanation is weak and flimsy given the historical and procedural conduct of the Defendant. The Plaintiff has demonstrated and the Defendant does not deny that the hearing notice was served on 14th June 2023 which is a full four months before the hearing. As stated in Shah v Mbogo(supra), a mistake ought to be "excusable"…

Paragraph 6 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS

COMM. CASE NO. E003 OF 2020

BETWEEN

TECHNO RELIEF SERVICES LIMITED………………………………..……PLAINTIFF

AND

COUNTY GOVERNMENT OF MACHAKOS………………………....DEFENDANT

RULING

Introduction & Background

1. The Defendant has filed two applications dated 20th December 2023 and 9th July 2024 seeking to set aside the ex parte proceedings of 18th October 2023, reopen the case for a de novo hearing on a priority basis and that the court allows it to participate by recalling the Plaintiff's witness for cross-examination and defending the suit. The Defendant also seeks to review, set aside, and/or vacate the ex parte judgment of 19th June 2024. The Plaintiff has responded to these applications through its replying affidavits sworn on 20th May 2024 and 16th September 2024 by Jigar Shah, its Tender & Product Development Officer. The applications have been canvassed by way of written submissions which are on record and I have considered the same together with the pleadings and where necessary, I will make relevant references to them in my analysis and determination below.

Analysis and Determination

2. Upon careful consideration of the pleadings and the submissions filed by the parties I note that the primary issue for determination is whether the court ought to review and set aside the ex parte proceedings of 18th October 2023 and the consequent judgment of 19th June 2024. I note that the Defendants’ applications are grounded under inter alia Order 10 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules which empowers the court to set aside or vary such judgment and any consequential decree or order upon terms that are just. I agree with the parties’ submissions that this power is discretionary and is intended to be exercised to avoid injustice or hardship resulting from accident, inadvertence or excusable mistake or error but it is not designed to assist a person who has deliberately sought whether by evasion or otherwise to obstruct or delay the cause of justice (see Mbogo & Another v Shah [1967] EA 116 and Richard Ncharpi Leiyagu v Independent Electoral Boundaries Commission & 2 others [2013] KECA 282 (KLR)]

3. Furthermore, in James Kanyiita Nderitu & another v Marios Philotas Ghikas & another [2016] KECA 470 (KLR), the Court of Appeal , while making a distinction between a regularly entered default judgment and an irregularly entered one, held as follows:

“From the outset, it cannot be gainsaid that a distinction has always existed between a default judgement that is regularly entered and one, which is irregularly entered. In a regular default judgement, the defendant will have been duly served with summons to enter appearance, but for one reason or another, he had failed to enter appearance or to file defence, resulting in default judgement. Such a defendant is entitled, under Order 10, Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules to move the court to set aside the default judgement and to grant him leave to defend the suit. In such a scenario, the court has unfettered discretion in determining whether or not to set aside the default judgement, and will take into account such factors as the reason for the failure of the defendant to file his memorandum of appearance or defence, as the case may be; the length of time that has elapsed since the default judgement was entered; whether the intended defence raises triable issues; the respective prejudice each party is likely to suffer; whether on the whole it is in the interest of justice to set aside the default judgement among others.

In an irregular default judgement, on the other hand, judgement will have been entered against a defendant who has not been served with summons to enter appearance. In such a situation, the default judgement is set aside ex debito justiciae, as a matter of right. The court does not even have to be moved by a party once it comes to its notice that the judgement is irregular; it can set aside the default judgement on its own motion. In addition, the court will not venture into consideration of whether the intended defence raises triable issues or whether there has been inordinate delay in applying to set aside the irregular judgement. The reason why such judgement is set aside as of right and not as a matter of discretion, is because the party against whom it is entered has been condemned without notice of those allegations. The right to be heard before an adverse decision is taken against a person is fundamental and permeates our entire justice system.’’

4. The Defendant depones that the Plaintiff's case proceeded ex parte on 18th October 2023 because the Defendant's counsel inadvertently failed to diarize the hearing date and the Defendant claims this was a mistake of counsel, which should not be visited upon it as the innocent client. The Defendant claims it has an arguable defence, stating that no monies are owed as the same were fully paid and that the matter involves public funds and it is in the interest of justice to allow the Defendant to cross-examine the Plaintiff's witness and present its defence. It further states that judgment was delivered on 19th June 2024, despite a pending application of 20th December 2023 that had not yet been determined and that the court had previously directed the matter to be mentioned on 26th June 2024 to take a ruling date for the pending application. It further states that the judgment was delivered in the absence of the parties, contrary to the court's own directions and can only be attributed to a mistake or grave error and the judgment is therefore irregular and should be set aside ex debito justitiae.

5. In response, the Plaintiff claims that the Defendant has had a history of non-attendance and it lists five separate dates between October 2021 and October 2023 where the Defendant or its advocates failed to attend court despite being served. It states that the Defendant failed to comply with pre-trial directions by not filing its List of Witnesses and Witness Statement, meaning it was not even ready for the hearing on 18th October 2023 and the Plaintiff contends that the Defendant has not provided sufficient cause as defined in law which requires a reason that is rational, plausible, logical, convincing, reasonable and truthful and that advocates must demonstrate genuine and acceptable mistakes, not outright negligence. The Plaintiff contends that the Defendant has not approached the court with clean hands, as it has repeatedly failed to attend court and comply with directions and as such prays that the applications be dismissed with costs since the Defendant has failed to discharge its burden to persuade the court to exercise its discretion in its favour.

6. Having gone through the pleadings and submissions, I am inclined to agree with the Plaintiff that the Defendant’s explanation is weak and flimsy given the historical and procedural conduct of the Defendant. The Plaintiff has demonstrated and the Defendant does not deny that the hearing notice was served on 14th June 2023 which is a full four months before the hearing. As stated in Shah v Mbogo(supra), a mistake ought to be "excusable" and I find that failing to diarize a date that was served four months in advance is straight up negligence and not an excusable inadvertence. The Plaintiff has listed five separate dates where the Defendant failed to attend court including 13th October 2021, 2nd February 2022, 19th October 2022, 13th June 2023 and the said 18th October 2023. While the Defendant's Supplementary Affidavit attempts to explain some of these away by claiming the judge was not sitting or the Plaintiff sought adjournments, I find that the sheer frequency of non-attendance creates a strong inference of a deliberate pattern of delay. I am in agreement with the Plaintiff that crucially, the Defendant had never filed its List of Witnesses and Witness Statement meaning even if counsel had attended court on 18th October 2023, the Defendant was not ready to proceed and this severely undermines the argument that the ex parte hearing deprived them of a meaningful opportunity to defend themselves.

7. I also agree that when the court emailed the parties on 13th June 2024 notifying them of the judgment date of 19th June 2024, the Defendant did not urgently apply to arrest the judgment. Instead, it waited until after the judgment was delivered to file the application on 9th July 2024, which in my view demonstrates a lack of bona fides.

8. I am persuaded by the decision of Peter Ngigi Kigira v Fredrick Nganga Kigira [2022] KEELC 1444 (KLR) cited by the Plaintiff that was upheld by the Court of Appeal in Kigira v Kigira [2025] KECA 146 (KLR) that repeated non-attendance is a "routine and a habit" that cannot be excused, stating, "It is excusable if it happens once but this is a routine and a habit and this Court will be bending backwards to stifle the smooth flow of the administration of justice." Furthermore, even if the court were to accept the diarization excuse and consider the merits of the defence ex debito justitiae, the same will not pass the muster and upstage the Plaintiff’s case. The Defendant claims that no monies are owed because they were fully paid and they rely on withholding certificates, payment schedules and a payment voucher from the Department of Water to support this claim. However, I find that the Defendant's defence is a bare denial as it does not provide a detailed breakdown of which LPOs were paid, how much was paid and how that corresponds to the Plaintiff's claim of Kshs.12,325,024.79. The Plaintiff produced LPOs, delivery notes duly stamped and signed acknowledging receipt, VAT withholding tax certificates and invoices and the Defendant did not call any witness to challenge this evidence or explain the documents.

9. It should not be lost that while the Defendant claims payment, the evidential burden shifts to it to prove it. The documents they rely on were filed in 2021 but were never tested through cross-examination or witness testimony and given the Plaintiff's detailed evidence of delivery and the Defendant's failure to substantiate its claim of full payment, the defence remains to be a mere denial.

10. It is also my finding that the Plaintiff correctly submits that a pending interlocutory application does not automatically operate as a stay of the main suit and the Defendant never obtained an order staying the judgment. The mention date of 26th June 2024 was for taking a ruling date on the application, not for staying the judgment and furthermore, the Defendant had failed to comply with the Deputy Registrar's directions of 3rd June 2024 to file its supplementary affidavit and submissions. As stated in James Kanyiita Nderitu(supra), an irregular judgment is one entered without service but in this case, the Defendant was served with the hearing notice and the judgment notice meaning the judgment is regular, and the court's discretion is discretionary and not mandatory.

11. In summary, that the failure to diarize a date served four months in advance, coupled with a history of non-attendance and non-compliance with pre-trial directions, does not constitute sufficient cause or an excusable mistake under to warrant the court’s discretion in favour of the Defendant. The Defendant's claim of full payment is a bare denial unsupported by cogent evidence, while the Plaintiff has produced stamped delivery notes and invoices. The judgment of 19th June 2024 was regularly entered and the Defendant failed to take timely steps to arrest it and I also note that the Defendant has not come to equity with clean hands, having repeatedly failed to comply with court directions.

Conclusion and Disposition

12. In the foregoing, the Defendant’s applications dated 20th December 2023 and 9th July 2024 are dismissed with costs.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED virtually this 27th DAY OF OCTOBER

2026

............................................................................

J W W MONGARE

JUDGE

In the presence of

1. Mr. Mutua for the Defendant

2. Ms. Waruhiu for the 2nd and 4th Respondent

3. Mr. Muriithi for Interested Party

4. Abdisalan- Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder