REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS
SUCCESSION CAUSE NO. 356 OF 2015
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF PHILIP KILONZO MWANZA (DECEASED)
EMMACULATE MWENDE MUTUA......SURVIVING ADMINISTRATOR/ APPLICANT
RULING
1. This ruling is on the summons dated 3.07.2025 filed by Emmaculate Mwende Mutua, the surviving Administrator/Applicant (hereinafter referred to as “the Applicant”) seeking, inter-alia, to appoint Diana Mutheu Mutua as an additional Administrator to act alongside the Applicant herein given that Teresia Waiu Mwanza who was a co-administrator with the Applicant has since passed on. The summons also seeks to have the mode of distribution approved at the confirmation on 17.2.2017 reviewed to reflect the true position since the impugned mode introduced complete strangers as beneficiaries to the estate.
2. The application is based on the grounds on its face, the supporting affidavit of the Applicant sworn on 3.7.2025 as well as the supplementary affidavit by Diana Mutheu Mutua (proposed co-administrator) sworn on 18.3.2026. The application intends to have the proposed co-administrator replace a deceased a co-administrator and to have the estate distributed to the rightful beneficiaries.
3. The application is opposed by Philip Nganga Kilonzo through his replying affidavit sworn on 17.12.2025 on the ground that he is an adopted son to Teresia Waiu Mwanza, (now deceased co-administrator) and that the grant as confirmed on 17.2.2017 and the estate partly distributed to him and one other person Elijah Maingi who is also said to be an adopted son to the said Teresia Waiu Mwanza (now deceased co-administrator).
4. Directions were given for the application to be canvassed by way of written submissions. Both parties complied.
5. I have carefully considered the Summons, the affidavits and submissions filed by the parties. This court will proceed to consider whether Diana Mutheu Mutua should be appointed as an additional Administrator to act alongside the Applicant herein given that Teresia Waiu Mwanza who was a co-administrator with the Applicant has since passed on and whether the mode of distribution approved at the confirmation on 17.2.2017 can be reviewed.
6. In the instant case, the deceased's estate was subjected to succession proceedings culminating in the issuance of a Grant of Letters of Administration Intestate on 4th December 2015, more than ten years ago, and the Certificate of Confirmation of the Grant was issued on 7th February 2017, more than eight years ago.
7. Upon confirmation of the Grant of Letters of Administration, this Court approved the mode of distribution and issued a Certificate of Confirmation of Grant, thereby conclusively settling the distribution of the estate and becoming functus officio on the matter of distribution of the estate.
8. One of the Administrators, Teresia Waiu Mwanza, died on 31st October 2023, before the estate was fully transmitted and distributed. The Certificate of Confirmation of Grant dated 7th February, 2025 has therefore remained valid, binding, unchallenged and unrevoked for over eight (8) years.
9. By the instant Summons dated 3rd July 2025, the Applicant seeks to substitute the named deceased co-administrator and to reopen and/or redistribute the estate relying on Sections 35, 37, and 40 of the Law of Succession Act and Rule 14 of the Probate and Administration Rules and thus seeks for the prayers stated hereinabove.
10. As to whether Diana Mutheu Mutua should be appointed as an additional Administrator to act alongside the Applicant following the demise of Teresia Waiu Mwanza who was a co-administrator, Section 81 of the said Law of Succession Act provides that; -
“Upon the death of one or more of several executors or administrators to whom a grant of representation has been made, all the powers and duties of the executors or administrators shall become vested in the survivors or survivor of them……(Emphasis added)
11. What is clear from the above provision is that, the Act does not contemplate substitution of a deceased co-administrator. The powers and duties of such deceased co-administrator vests in the surviving co-administrator. As such, in the instant case, upon the death of Teresia Waiu Mwanza, in the absence of a continuing trust, her duties and powers automatically and by operation of law vested in the surviving co- administrator Emmaculate Mwende Mutua, the Applicant.
12. In the persuasive authority of In re Estate of Tuaruchiu Marete Marete alias M’turuchiu M’marete alias Turuchiu S/O Marete (Deceased) (Succession Cause 82 of 1989) [2019] KEHC 10486 (KLR) (30th January 2019) (Judgment), Justice F. Gikonyo expounded on the instances where an additional Administrator can be appointed to substitute a deceased administrator. The Learned Judge held that:-
“(11) There are however situations where an additional administrator should be appointed. For instance, where there is a resulting trust, a sole surviving administrator is required to apply for an additional administrator to be appointed which failing the court will appoint on its own motion. Similarly, where the intestate is polygamous, death of one of the administrators may require a replacement for purposes of the house he represented. Or for a good cause and in the best interest of all persons concerned the court may appoint an additional administrator of an estate. This is in discretion under section 66 of the Law of Succession Act. Therefore, there is no complete prohibition of appointing another administrator in addition to a surviving administrator or administrators. Nothing wrong in the appointment of the first administrator herein.”
13. In this case, the Certificate of Confirmation of Grant was duly confirmed on 7th February 2017. The statutory stage at which those provisions apply was conclusively settled. Upon confirmation, the approved schedule of distribution crystallized into vested proprietary interests in favour of the named beneficiaries.
14. Once the court issues the certificate of confirmation of the grant, as it did in this case on the 7th February 2017, it becomes functus officio. In Mulungye v Kisangi & Another (Family Appeal E004 of 2021) [2025] KEHC 9430 (KLR) (28 March 2025) (Judgment), the Court, while citing Estate of Daniel Khasievera Anusu (Deceased), where the court held :-
"The High Court handled this matter while sitting as a probate court. Its remit as such is limited to the distribution of the assets of the estate.... The probate court is pretty functus officio. once it confirms the grant ....What follows confirmation of a grant is transmission of the assets to the named beneficiaries as per or according to the certificate of confirmation of grant... I even doubt whether the High Court has any jurisdiction to touch anything to do with the transmission of property after confirmation of the grant. "
15. Guided by the provisions of Section 81 of the Law of Succession Act, with no situation for appointment of an additional Administrator having been demonstrated by the Applicant and being persuaded by foregoing decision, I am of the considered view that this court cannot allow the prayer seeking to have Diana Mutheu Mutua appointed as an additional Administrator to act alongside the Applicant.
16. As to whether the mode of distribution approved at the confirmation on 17.2.2017 can be reviewed. The Summons neither invokes nor satisfies the statutory threshold of reviewing the Certificate of Confirmation of Grant. There are no new assets discovered and or new beneficiaries who were not available during the confirmation.
17. It is trite that Review is only permissible if there is discovery of new assets or new heirs, or new beneficiaries who were not heard during the confirmation. Where assets are discovered after the court has confirmed the grant or heir or survivor of the deceased who had previously been unheard of, materializes after distribution, the court may review its orders made at the point of confirming the grant on the ground of discovery of new and important evidence that was not available at the time the grant was being confirmed." (See, In the matter of the estate of Geoffrey Kinuthia Nyamwinga (Deceased) [2013] KEHC 3745 (KLR).
18. Similarly, In re estate of Charles Kibe Karania (deceased) [2015] eKLR, it was held that:-
"If a party wishes to have the assets of the estate redistributed or there is discovery of new assets that were not available or had not been discovered at the time of distribution. among others, it would be imprudent to seek rectification or alteration or amendment of the certificate of confirmation of grant. Such changes are fundamental, not superficial. They go to the core of the distribution. They cannot be affected without touching the orders made by the Court at the distribution of the estate. Consequently, such changes cannot and should not be effected through a mere amendment of the certificate of confirmation of grant. The proper approach ought to be an application for review of the orders made at the confirmation of the grant. The remedy of review of Court orders is not directly provided for in the Law of Succession Act and the Probate and Administration Rules, but it is imported into probate practice by Rule 63 of Probate and Administration Rules, which has adopted a number of procedures from the Civil Procedure Rules”.
19. The record in these proceedings shows that the Applicant was aware of and participated in the confirmation process. The proposed co-administrator is not a newly discovered heir, nor has any new evidence been presented that was unavailable at the time of confirmation. The Applicant pleaded by offering her consent during the confirmation process. She is bound to that consent.
20. In substance, the instant application seeks redistribution of an estate already distributed by a valid Court Order. Such relief cannot be granted under the provisions cited by the Applicant and in the manner the application as pleaded.
21. In the end, it is hereby ordered as follows:
1. The Summons dated 3rd July 2025 lacks merit and the same is hereby dismissed with no order as to costs this being a family matter.
2. The Confirmed Grant dated 17th January 2017 remains valid, binding, and unrevoked, therefore, Emmaculate Mwende Mutua, the surviving Administrator/Applicant herein is ordered to proceed and complete the transmission and distribution of the estate including distribution of the same to the estates of any deceased beneficiaries named in the Summons for Confirmation of Grant pursuant to the mode of distribution thereof.
3. This cause shall be mentioned after six (6) months to confirm compliance with these orders and for further orders and/or directions of the court.
RULIND DATED & SIGNED AT MACHAKOS THIS 28TH OCTOBER 2026
NOEL I. ADAGI
JUDGE
DELIVERED VIRTUALLY ON TEAMS AT MACHAKOS THIS 28TH OCTOBER 2026
In the presence of: