Civil law

Signature Tours & Travel Limited v National Bank of Kenya Limited [2026] KEHC 17451 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Case number
Civil Case 4 of 2017
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
E. N. Maina

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Defendant/Applicant moves the Court by a Notice of Motion dated 24th September 2025, brought under sections 22 and 23 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 16 rules 1 and 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. It seeks the following orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

From the submissions of both parties, the Court identifies the following issue for determination:

Paragraph 14 →

Reasoning passage

The Plaintiff's central objection is that the records existed all along and could have been obtained with reasonable diligence. I am not persuaded on this record. A search of the registry depends on the registration numbers of the vehicles. The evidence on who was to provide a complete list of the 180 vehicles points both ways. PW1 stated that the Court required the Bank to list the vehicles it purchased and that it did not, and he…

Paragraph 21 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Defendant’s application to re-open its case, for the limited purpose of producing certified NTSA registration records concerning vehicles in the Plaintiff’s Further List of Documents, was merited; and whether NTSA should be summoned to produce the…

Material facts

The dispute concerns ownership and financing of vehicles acquired under asset-finance facilities from the Defendant. After the original hearing closed, the Court directed reports on the financed vehicles and facility disbursements. The Plaintiff’s Further…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS

CIVIL CASE NO. 4 OF 2017

SIGNATURE TOURS & TRAVEL LIMITED…………………….PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

NATIONAL BANK OF KENYA LIMITED ....DEFENDANT

RULING

1. The Defendant/Applicant moves the Court by a Notice of Motion dated 24th September 2025, brought under sections 22 and 23 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 16 rules 1 and 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. It seeks the following orders:

“(i) That the Defendant's case be re-opened and leave be granted to file certified copies of the registration records maintained by the National Transport and Safety Authority (the NTSA) for the motor vehicles listed in the Plaintiff's Further List of Documents dated 17th September 2024.

(ii) That, once leave is granted, the records be filed within seven days.

(iii) That witness summons issue to the NTSA, as custodian of the records, for an appropriate officer to attend and produce them.

(iv) That costs of the motion be in the cause.”

2. The motion is supported by the affidavit of Chrispus Maithya, the Defendant's Head of Commercial Transactions and Litigation, sworn on 24th September 2025. The Plaintiff opposes it.

3. The dispute between the parties concerns, among other things, the ownership and financing of motor vehicles acquired under asset finance facilities with the Defendant. It was heard together with the related suit, Machakos High Court Civil Case No. 21 of 2018. The Plaintiff's witnesses testified on 25th October 2023 and 21st November 2023, after which the Plaintiff closed its case. The Defendant called a single witness, Nancy Naswa, who testified on 13th February 2024 and was cross-examined and re-examined on 31st July 2024, when the Defendant's case closed.

4. After the close of the hearing, the Court directed the Plaintiff to file a detailed list of the motor vehicles alleged to have been financed by the Defendant, including those in which the Defendant failed to perfect security under the consent order recorded in Nairobi High Court Civil Case No. 101 of 2016. It directed the Defendant to file a report on how the amounts in the letters of offer were utilized, identifying the dealer, the make of vehicle and the amounts disbursed. The Plaintiff complied through its Further List of Documents dated 17th September 2024, which is headed "List of all the financed vehicles" and sets out 180 vehicles by registration number and type. The Defendant filed its Further List and Bundle of Documents dated 18th November 2024. On 5th December 2024 the Court, then differently constituted, directed that the hearing be re-opened, limited to the reports filed by the parties. The record also shows that the Plaintiff had asked to re-open the hearing in order to cross-examine a witness on the reports, and that the request was allowed.

5. The re-opened hearing proceeded on 21st July 2025 with one witness for each party. PW1, Koome Munene, a director of the Plaintiff, adopted the Plaintiff's list and testified on how the vehicles were financed and on the registration of some of them. In cross-examination he stated that, under the consent order adopted in Nairobi High Court Civil Case No. 101 of 2016, the Plaintiff undertook to provide a comprehensive list of the 180 vehicles and was to provide their logbooks, and that it did not. DW2, Paul Chelanga, the Defendant's Manager, Remedial and Recoveries, testified on how the facility funds were utilized. He stated that the Defendant purchased nine vehicles and that the others were taken over from Standard Chartered Bank, and that for the takeover the Defendant relied on a bank to bank undertaking and did not wait for the documents.

6. The Defendant's application arose during that hearing. While PW1 was under cross-examination, counsel for the Defendant told the Court that, since receiving the list of 180 vehicles, the Defendant had carried out historical searches of 179 of them, with one outstanding, and sought leave to produce the results. Counsel for the Plaintiff stated that the matter had not come to his attention until that day and that he had no instructions. The Court directed that the witnesses be heard and that a formal application be filed and served within 15 days, with the Plaintiff to respond within 15 days thereafter. The Defendant filed the present motion, dated 24th September 2025. On 29th September 2025 its counsel confirmed that the motion had been filed albeit late, and the Plaintiff sought and was granted 14 days to respond.

7. The Defendant's application is based on the following grounds:

“(i) The list of the 180 vehicles was not known to the Defendant during the trial or before the Court's direction.

(ii) The registration records are public documents relevant to the ownership of the vehicles, which the Defendant says were owned by the Plaintiff and financed by the Defendant.

(iii) Their production is important for the just determination of the dispute.”

8. In his supporting affidavit, Mr. Maithya deposes that the Defendant was not previously in a position to avail the evidence. He states that the Defendant "has so far succeeded in retrieving 179 certified copies of registration records" maintained by the NTSA, which are annexed as "CM 2", and that their production serves substantive justice under Article 159 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

9. The Plaintiff/Respondent opposes the motion through Grounds of Opposition dated 5th March 2026, which states as follows:

“(i) The Defendant seeks to adduce evidence which it had, or was in a position to have, from the time the suit was filed.

(ii) The Defendant seeks to plug holes in its case long after both parties closed their cases.

(iii) The Plaintiff will be prejudiced by being ambushed with evidence long after the close of the trial.

(iv) The evidence is not new, having existed all along.

(v) The motion is brought late in the day and will further delay the proceedings to the Plaintiff's detriment.”

The Submissions

10. The Defendant's written submissions dated 8th May 2026 were filed out of time but were deemed as duly filed on 11th May 2026. The Defendant submits that the Court's jurisdiction to re-open a case and receive further evidence derives from sections 22 and 23 of the Civil Procedure Act, which it says allow the Court to order the admission of documents and to summon persons to give evidence or produce documents, and from section 146(4) of the Evidence Act read with Order 18 rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, which allow a witness to be recalled. It relies on the six principles distilled by Eboso J in the case of Susan Wavinya Mutavi v Isaac Njoroge & another [2020] KEELC 8 (KLR), and applies them in turn.

11. On prejudice, the Defendant submits that the Plaintiff will not be embarrassed or prejudiced and that it is the Defendant that would be prejudiced, because the list of vehicles was not within its knowledge before the Court's directions and it must be able to test the Plaintiff's assertion that the vehicles were financed, purchased or jointly registered in the names of the Plaintiff or the Bank. On gaps, it submits that the application is not meant to fill any gap in its evidence but responds to a list presented after the close of the hearing, and that admitting the records would level the playing field. On delay, it submits that having received the list it engaged the NTSA, and that the records sought were historical records running from first registration, so that they were secured and presented in a timely manner. On diligence, it submits that the records could not have been obtained during the hearing and that by the re-opened hearing it had secured them and sought leave at once. On influence, it submits that the Plaintiff alleges the 180 vehicles were jointly registered in its name and the Bank's, so that the Bank should hold sufficient security, and that the records go to the reliability of that list. On credibility, it submits that the records come from the custodian of the public record of all motor vehicles registered in Kenya.

12. The Plaintiff filed written submissions dated 2nd July 2026. It identifies a single issue, which is whether the Court should exercise its discretion to re-open the trial to allow the Defendant to tender additional evidence. It submits that no express provision allows a trial court to re-open pleadings and admit additional evidence, and that principles have instead emerged over time. It relies on the summary of those principles by Eboso J in the case of Mutavi (supra). The learned Judge there held that the jurisdiction is discretionary and must be exercised without embarrassing or prejudicing the opposite party, that re-opening to fill gaps in the applicant's evidence will not be granted, that inordinate and unexplained delay defeats the plea, that the applicant must show the evidence could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence, that the evidence must probably have an important influence on the result, and that it must be apparently credible. The Plaintiff also relies on the authorities collected in that decision, among them the case of Samuel Kiti Lewa v Housing Finance Company of Kenya Limited & another [2015] KEHC 3930 (KLR).

13. Applying those principles, the Plaintiff submits that admitting the evidence will prejudice it and delay the proceedings. It submits that a party cannot rely on matters that arose during the testimony of the other side's witnesses to plug holes in its case, that the Defendant has not shown that it only recently came across the documentation, and that the Defendant already adduced some of the motor vehicle logbooks when its own witness testified. It further submits that the Defendant is guilty of undue delay in bringing the motion.

Issues for Determination

14. From the submissions of both parties, the Court identifies the following issue for determination:

(i) Whether the application is merited and the Defendant's case should be re-opened to allow the additional evidence.

Analysis and Determination

15. The Supreme Court set out the principles that guide the admission of additional evidence in the case of Hon. Mohamed Abdi Mahamud v Ahmed Abdullahi Mohamad & 3 others, Petition Nos. 7 and 9 of 2018 (Consolidated) [2018] KESC 62 (KLR). The Court held that it would allow additional evidence only in exceptional circumstances, on a case by case basis, and sparingly. The first of the principles it laid down is that:

"the additional evidence must be directly relevant to the matter before the court and be in the interest of justice;"

16. The Supreme Court restated the remaining principles in the case of Attorney General v Zinj Limited, Petition 1 of 2020 [2021] KESC 63 (KLR) (5 March 2021) (Ruling). Those material to this motion are that:

“(i) The evidence must be such that, if given, it would influence or impact upon the result, though it need not be decisive.

(ii) It must be shown that the evidence could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence for use at the trial.

(iii) The evidence must be credible, in the sense that it is capable of belief.

(iv) The evidence must not be so voluminous as to make it difficult or impossible for the other party to respond effectively.

(v) Whether the party would reasonably have been aware of and procured the evidence in the course of the trial is an essential consideration.

(vi) The court must be satisfied that the evidence is not used for the purpose of removing lacunae or filling gaps in the evidence.

(vii) The court will consider the proportionality and prejudice of allowing the additional evidence.”

17. These principles were affirmed in the case of Janmohamed (Suing as the Executrix of the Estate of the Late HE Daniel Toroitich Arap Moi) & another v Lagat & 3 others, Petition Nos. 17 (E021) and 24 (E027) of 2022 (Consolidated) [2023] KESC 59 (KLR), as follows:

"This court in Hon Mohamed Abdi Mahamud (supra) emphasized that even with the application of the set principles, the court will only allow additional evidence on a case-by-case basis and even then, sparingly with abundant caution."

18. These decisions arose on applications to adduce additional evidence on appeal, under section 20 of the Supreme Court Act and the Supreme Court Rules, 2020. I also take into consideration the case of Mutavi (supra), relied on by counsel for both parties, which distilled the same considerations into six principles.

19. Having considered the motion, the supporting affidavit, the Grounds of Opposition, the written submissions of both parties and the applicable law, I analyse the issue as follows.

20. On relevance and credibility, the Plaintiff does not contest either in its Grounds of Opposition or in its submissions. The records are certified copies of registration records held by a statutory authority. The evidence at the re-opened hearing placed the registration and financing history of the vehicles in issue. PW1 testified on the registration of some vehicles and on which bank financed them, and DW2 testified that the Defendant purchased nine vehicles and took over the rest from Standard Chartered Bank. Registration histories bear directly on those matters. The Defendant points out that the Plaintiff's case is that the vehicles were jointly registered in its name and the Defendant's, so that the Defendant held security over them, and the records are capable of testing that case and of influencing the result. Those limbs are satisfied.

21. The Plaintiff's central objection is that the records existed all along and could have been obtained with reasonable diligence. I am not persuaded on this record. A search of the registry depends on the registration numbers of the vehicles. The evidence on who was to provide a complete list of the 180 vehicles points both ways. PW1 stated that the Court required the Bank to list the vehicles it purchased and that it did not, and he also accepted that the Plaintiff undertook in 2016 to provide the logbooks of the 180 vehicles and did not do so. Whichever party was in default, the complete list of registration numbers was first placed before the Court by the Plaintiff on 17th September 2024, on the Court's direction and after the Defendant's case had closed. DW2 further explained that for the Standard Chartered Bank takeover the Defendant relied on a bank to bank undertaking and did not obtain the documents, so that it did not hold the registration documents for those vehicles. The Plaintiff submits that the Defendant produced some logbooks through its own witness, but that does not show that the Defendant could have searched the registration history of the entire list before the list existed. I find that the Defendant has shown that the records could not reasonably have been obtained for use at the trial.

22. On delay, the timeline must be read as a whole. By 21st July 2025 the Defendant had searched 179 of the 180 vehicles on the list, and it told the Court so at the first opportunity at the re-opened hearing. Counsel for the Plaintiff was informed that day. The Defendant was directed to file within 15 days and filed on 24th September 2025, about seven weeks out of time. It acknowledged the lateness on 29th September 2025, the Plaintiff did not object but sought 14 days to respond, and the Court gave directions. The Plaintiff's Grounds of Opposition were then dated 5th March 2026, some months after the time it had asked for. Much of the time that has passed since the motion cannot be laid at the Defendant's door. I am persuaded by the decision of Justice Kasango in the case of Kiti Lewa (supra) that an unexplained and inordinate delay will defeat an application to re-open a case. That case concerned a plaintiff who waited about four years without explanation. This is not such a case. The delay here is of weeks, it was acknowledged, and it has not been shown to have prejudiced the Plaintiff.

23. The Plaintiff also contends that the Defendant seeks to plug holes in its case. In my opinion, that principle is aimed at a party who closes its case and then, having seen the other side's evidence, tries to improve it. That is not what has happened here. The hearing was re-opened at the Plaintiff's request, limited to the reports the Court had called for, and one witness for each party was heard. The Plaintiff's own evidence put the registration of the vehicles in issue, and the records go to test the Plaintiff's list, which the Court itself required. To refuse the Defendant what the Plaintiff was allowed would leave the parties on an unequal footing. The records are also not evidence that the Defendant withheld from its case in chief. They respond to a list that did not exist when it closed.

24. On proportionality and prejudice, the Supreme Court cautions against additional evidence so voluminous that the other party cannot respond effectively. The records are 179 certified copies of a single kind, drawn from a public registry, and the Plaintiff has had the opportunity to examine them since the motion was served. Any prejudice can be met by terms that allow the Plaintiff to respond to the records. The suit was filed in 2017 and the Plaintiff's concern about further delay is real, but it is answered by fixing short timelines. Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 directs that justice be administered without undue regard to procedural technicalities, and it applies here because the records bear on matters the Court must decide on a full record.

25. In the result, the Defendant has satisfied the criteria for re-opening its case to the limited extent of producing the registration records, and the issue is answered in the affirmative.

26. On the prayer for witness summons to the NTSA, the records are certified copies of public documents and the Plaintiff has not so far challenged their authenticity. The prayer is therefore not necessary at this stage. If the Plaintiff disputes the records, it should be at liberty to apply for an officer of the NTSA to be summoned for cross-examination.

27. On costs, the motion was filed during the hearing and has taken long to determine it because of delays on both sides. The costs of the motion shall be in the cause

Disposition

28. For the reasons set out above, this court makes the following orders:

(i)The Defendant's case is re-opened to the limited extent of the production of certified copies of the National Transport and Safety Authority registration records for the motor vehicles listed in the Plaintiff's Further List of Documents dated 17th September 2024.

(ii)The Defendant shall file and serve the records within seven (7) days of the date of publishing this ruling.

(iii) The prayer for witness summons to the National Transport and Safety Authority is not granted.

(iv)The costs of the motion shall be in the cause.

Orders accordingly.

Ruling dated, signed and delivered virtually via Microsoft teams on this 29th day of October, 2026.

E. N. MAINA

JUDGE

In the presence of:

No appearance by either side

Miriam – Court Assistant/Interpreter

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder