REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS
CRIMINAL CASE NO. 11 OF 2020
REPUBLIC………………………………………………..…..........PROSECUTOR
VERSUS
MWANZA KALOKI…………………………………………………….ACCUSED
RULING
1. The accused person, Mwanza Kaloki, is charged with two counts of murder contrary to section 203 as read with section 204 of the Penal Code. In count one it is alleged that on 28th January 2020 at Malindi Village, Kyanzansu Sub-location, Kimutwa Location in Kalama Sub-County within Machakos County, he murdered Angela Ndinda Kaloki. In count two it is alleged that on the same date and at the same place he murdered Faith Mutheu Mbithi. He pleaded not guilty to both counts on 22 September 2021 and the matter proceeded to hearing. This ruling is on whether the prosecution has established a prima facie case under section 306 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
2. The prosecution called seven witnesses and closed its case on 21st May 2026.
3. PW1, Esther Mutindi, testified in Kikamba that Angela Ndinda Kaloki was her mother-in-law and that Faith Mutheu Mbithi was her daughter. She told the Court that the accused person is her husband’s brother, known to her as Mwanzia Kaloki, and she pointed him out in the dock. She testified that on 28th January 2020 at about 6 pm she went to the shamba for vegetables and then began cooking at home. She heard children running, came out of the house and saw the children running towards their house. She stated that Faith fell, that a boy got inside the house and that the accused person began cutting Faith with a panga. She stated that he followed the boy into the house holding a panga, that she told him she was going to the shop to buy onions and that she ran off with the boy. She stated that he pursued them, that she sustained an injury on the leg while fleeing and that she was treated at Machakos Level 5 Hospital. She described the cuts to Faith as about seven to the head, followed by cuts to the face and the belly. She stated that the accused person cut his mother as well as Faith. She identified a panga held by a police officer as the one he used (PMFI-3).
4. PW1 further testified that on the same day the accused person and his mother quarreled over eggs. She stated that the accused person put his mother’s eggs in a sufuria while holding a panga and that when his mother asked him why he was cooking her eggs he said he would kill her. She stated that her mother-in-law sent Faith to fetch a timber plank, that the accused person said one cannot beat a person holding a panga with a piece of timber and that he cut Faith on the head so that the plank fell. In cross-examination she stated that the relationship between the accused person and his mother was hostile and that they quarreled all the time. She stated that she was outside washing clothes, that she went into the house to get clothes and that on coming out she found her mother-in-law had fallen. She stated that she saw him holding a panga and hacking her mother-in-law, beginning with the head, and that he did not cut her but ran after her with a panga raised. In re-examination she stated that the accused person wanted to be given land and that this was the cause of the bad relationship.
5. PW2, Boniface Wambua, a tailor from Kyathanzu in Makueni County, testified that Ndinda Kaloki’s husband is his brother and that the accused person is the son of Angela Ndinda. He stated that on 28 January 2020 at about 5 pm he saw people going home from school and heard them say that their grandmother had been killed. He went to the home and found Angela lying outside the door of her house with two cuts on the hand and a cut on the head. He also found a girl lying on the ground with a cut on the head who was dead. He stated that the wife of Mbithi was present and that a search for the accused person began that day. The accused person was not found that day. He testified that he had earlier been called to the home to settle a domestic dispute after the accused person slaughtered a goat and that the matter was reported to Kwakatheke Police Post. He produced photographs of Angela and Faith (PMFI-1, 2(a) and 2(b)). In cross-examination he stated that he did not witness the events of 28th January 2020, that he did not see the weapon and that he was not present at the arrest. He stated that no OB number was obtained for the goat report and that what he knew of the goat incident was what he was told.
6. PW3, Rose Ndunge, a farmer from Malindi Village, testified that Angela Kaloki was her mother, that Faith Mutheu Mbithi was the daughter of her brother Fredrick Mbithi and that the accused person is her last-born brother. She stated that on 28th January 2020 she was called by Janet Mulei and went to her mother’s home on a motorcycle. She found her mother’s body at the door of the house and found that the child had also been killed, each having been cut on the head. She found PW1 at the scene and did not find the accused person. The assistant chief and the village elder were called and the police took the bodies to Machakos mortuary. She identified her mother’s body for the post mortem and identified the post mortem forms. She stated that the accused person had many issues, which were reported to Boda AP Post. In cross-examination she stated that she did not witness the events and that when her mother reported the accused person she went together with their uncle Dominic and no action was taken.
7. PW4, Dr. Waithera Ajengo, a consultant pathologist in Machakos County, testified that she holds an MBChB (2007) and a Master’s degree in Human Pathology (2013) from the University of Nairobi. She stated that she performed the post mortem on the body of Ndinda Mutua and recorded the cause of death as loss of blood due to cut wounds, more so on the head. She stated that she performed the post mortem on Faith Mutheu Mbithi, whose clothes were soaked in blood, and recorded the cause of death as excessive loss of blood secondary to cuts on the head. Blood samples were taken from both bodies for DNA and handed to the police. She produced the post mortem forms (EXBP-1 and EXBP-1A). She stated that the probable weapon was a sharp object such as a panga and that the injuries on both were similar. In cross-examination she stated that she did not ascertain who committed the act.
8. PW5, Jennifer Muinde, the assistant chief of Kyanzansu Sub-location, testified that at about 6 pm on 28th January 2020 she was called by the village elder and went to the home of Angela Ndinda Kaloki. She found two bodies, those of Angela Ndinda and Faith Mutheu, who had been cut with a sharp object. Officers from Machakos Police Station took photographs and the bodies were taken to the mortuary. She stated that the accused person lived in his mother’s homestead, where the bodies were found, and that he was not at home on 28th January 2020. She testified that towards the end of 2019 Angela came to her office claiming that the accused person had killed a goat, that on being questioned he had said he would do something terrible and that she advised Angela to report to Konza Police Station. She identified photographs of Angela and Faith (MFI-2A).
9. PW5 further testified that she later received a call from Dominic Mutua, who said that they had seen the suspect hiding somewhere and named him as Mwanzia Kaloki. She called the OCS Machakos, who sent officers, and the accused person was rescued. She stated that Dominic Mutua gave her a panga, that she took it to her office and that officers from Machakos collected it. She stated that the panga seemed to have blood on the blade and identified it as the one marked MFI-P3. In cross-examination she stated that the panga was not at the scene, that it was given to her by Dominic and that she could not say with certainty that it was with the accused person.
10. PW6, Cpl Antony Wangunya, the investigating officer, testified that on 28th January 2020 at about 5 pm he was instructed to go to Malindi Village with PC Wekesa and a driver. At the compound of Fredrick Mbithi he found two bodies lying in the compound. He stated that the woman, named Ndinda, had injuries on the head and elbow and that the child had injuries on the head, with blood oozing from both. The woman’s body was near her house while the child’s was near their house, just a few metres away. He stated that Fredrick Mbithi was present, that Esther Mutindi (PW1) was interrogated and recorded a statement after initially being in shock, and that the accused person’s house was adjacent to his mother’s and that the accused person and Fredrick Mbithi lived in the same homestead. He stated that a boy was a direct eyewitness, that he did not recall recording his statement and that he did not interrogate him because he was in a state of shock. Photographs of the bodies were taken with the assistance of officers from Konza Police Station.
11. PW6 further testified that he received information that the accused person had been seen hiding in a house, that he found about 200 people there and that village managers and community policing members protected the accused person from the crowd. He stated that stones were thrown as the accused person was escorted to the vehicle, that he shot in the air and that the crowd dispersed. He took the accused person to Machakos Police Station where he was charged. He stated that the post mortems were conducted by Dr. Waithera on 3rd February 2020 and that the introductory part of the post mortem forms was filled by PC Herbert Wekesa. He testified that EXBP-1 records the name Ndinda Mutua Muili and that the name Angela was then added. He stated that from his investigations the accused person used to complain that he was not loved, that he demanded to be given his land and that he complained of not being given enough food by his mother, Angela Ndinda, who is deceased. He stated that Faith Mutheu was the accused person’s niece. He placed the accused person with a panga, which was recovered after it had been washed. He produced the panga (EXBP-3) and identified the photographs (MFI-P2A).
12. In cross-examination PW6 stated that the panga was not dusted for fingerprints or taken for forensic investigation because it had been washed and time had passed. He stated that they returned with the panga, that it was the accused person’s and that it was the accused person who went back with it. He stated that there were allegations made by the accused person’s family, that the accused person had been given a portion of land to cultivate and that he was not certain that the accusations had been reported to the police.
13. PW7, Chief Inspector Ndunda Morris, a crime scene officer, testified that he certified twelve photographs brought to him by the investigating officer, PW6. The photographs show the deceased persons and their injuries, a bed without a mattress, a blue cap, a red substance thought to be blood beside the house and a broken window. He produced them as EXBP-2(a), 2(b) and 2(c). He stated that it is procedural for another officer to take photographs on his behalf and that it is not mandatory for him to visit the scene. In cross-examination he stated that the window was of interest because the perpetrator used it to gain entry into the house.
14. At the close of the prosecution case the parties were directed to file written submissions, the prosecution within 21 days and the defence within 14 days after service. As at the date of this ruling, no submissions had been filed.
Issues for Determination
15. Having considered the law, the following issues arise for determination:
(i) Whether the prosecution has led evidence on the fact and cause of death of the deceased persons.
(ii) Whether there is evidence that the accused person unlawfully caused the deaths of the deceased persons with malice aforethought.
Analysis and Determination
16. The Court is guided by the decision of the Court of Appeal for Eastern Africa in the case of Ramanlal Trambaklal Bhatt v Republic [1957] EA 332 where it was stated:
“It is true, as Wilson, J., said, that the court is not required at that stage to decide finally whether the evidence is worthy of credit, or whether if believed it is weighty enough to prove the case conclusively; that final determination can only properly be made when the case for the defence has been heard. It may not be easy to define what is meant by a prima facie case, but at least it must mean one on which a reasonable tribunal, properly directing its mind to the law and the evidence could convict if no explanation is offered by the defence.”
17. The Court does not determine culpability but confines its assessment of the prosecution case to what is necessary to determine whether a prima facie case has been made out, so as not to prejudge the defence. Section 306(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code requires the Court to record a finding of not guilty where it considers that there is no evidence that the accused or any one of several accused committed the offence. Where there is such evidence, the accused is put on his defence under section 306(2).
18. In the case of Anthony Ndegwa Ngari v Republic [2014] KECA 424 (KLR) the elements of murder were stated as:
“For the offence of murder, there are three elements which the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt in order to secure a conviction. They are: (a) the death of the deceased and the cause of that death; (b) that the accused committed the unlawful act which caused the death of the deceased and (c) that the Accused had the malice aforethought.”
19. The Court considers each element against the issues framed.
Whether the prosecution has led evidence on the fact and cause of death of the deceased persons
20. PW1 and PW3 testified to the deaths of Angela Ndinda Kaloki and Faith Mutheu Mbithi. PW4 performed the post mortems and identified the cause of death in the first as loss of blood due to cut wounds, more so on the head, and in the second as excessive loss of blood secondary to cuts on the head. The prosecution has led evidence on the fact and cause of death of both deceased persons.
Whether there is evidence that the accused person unlawfully caused the deaths of the deceased persons with malice aforethought
21. The prosecution case on this issue rests mainly on the direct evidence of PW1.
22. The Court is guided by the decision of the Court of Appeal in the case of Reuben Taabu Anjononi & 2 Others v Republic [1980] KECA 23 (KLR) where it was observed:
“recognition of an assailant is more satisfactory, more assuring, and more reliable than identification of a stranger because it depends upon the personal knowledge of the assailant in some form or other.”
23. PW1 testified that she knows the accused person as her husband’s brother. PW5 testified that he lived in his mother’s homestead and PW6 testified that he and Fredrick Mbithi lived in the same homestead. PW1 testified that she saw the accused person cut Faith with a panga, follow the boy into the house and pursue her with a panga raised. She narrated in detail the events leading up to the deaths.
24. PW6 testified that the panga produced as EXBP-3 was the accused person’s.
25. Taking the prosecution evidence at its best, there is prima facie evidence that the accused person wielded a panga and that he was seen using it against the deceased persons, which is connected to their cause of death.
26. Section 206 of the Penal Code provides:
“Malice aforethought shall be deemed to be established by evidence proving any one or more of the following circumstances:-
(a)An intention to cause the death of or to do grievous harm to any person, whether that person is the person actually killed or not;
(b) Knowledge that the act or omission causing death will probably cause the death of or grievous harm to some person, whether that person is the person actually killed or not, although such knowledge is accompanied by indifference whether death or grievous bodily harm is caused or not, or by a wish that it may not be caused;
(c) An intent to commit a felony;
(d) An intention by the act or omission to facilitate the flight or escape from custody of any person who has committed or attempted to commit a felony.”
27. PW4 found that both deceased persons died of loss of blood from cut wounds, mainly on the head, and that the probable weapon was a sharp object such as a panga. PW1 testified that Faith was cut about seven times on the head and that when his mother asked the accused person why he was cooking her eggs he said he would kill her. If that evidence is believed, a reasonable tribunal could consider whether an intention to cause death or grievous harm, or knowledge that death or grievous harm would probably result, is established.
28. A prima facie case has therefore been made out and the accused should be placed on his defence.
Disposition
29. The Court makes the following orders:
(i) A prima facie case has been established against the accused person, Mwanza Kaloki, on both counts of murder contrary to Section 203 as read with Section 204 of the Penal Code.
(ii) The accused person is placed on his defence under Section 306(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code.
It is so ordered.
Ruling dated, signed and delivered virtually via Microsoft teams on this 29th day of October, 2026.
E. N. MAINA
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Madam Otieno for the State
No appearance for Mr. Muteti Advocate for the accused
The Accused person
Miriam – Court Assistant/Interpreter