REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS
CIVIL DIVISION
JUDICIAL REVIEW CASE NO. E011 OF 2025
IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION FOR CONTEMPT OF COURT
BETWEEN
AGNES MWIKALI MAINA APPLICANT
VERSUS
THE COUNTY SECRETARY, MACHAKOS COUNTY 1ST RESPONDENT
CHIEF OFFICER, FINANCE, MACHAKOS COUNTY 2ND RESPONDENT
COUNTY EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEMBER, FINANCE AND ECONOMIC PLANNING, MACHAKOS COUNTY 3RD RESPONDENT
RULING
1. This ruling determines the Notice of Motion dated 10th April 2026, brought under sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 63 of the Civil Procedure Act, Cap 21 and Order 51 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Applicant seeks the following orders against the County Secretary, Machakos County, the Chief Officer, Finance, Machakos County and the County Executive Committee Member, Finance and Economic Planning, Machakos County (the Respondents) for disobeying the order of mandamus given by this Court on 11th March 2026 (the order):
“(i) An order of committal to prison for six months against the Respondents for contempt of the order.
(ii) An order that the Officer Commanding Station, Machakos Police Station, or the Court Bailiff arrest and detain the Respondents and produce them before this Court for committal.
(iii) An order that the Respondents be held jointly and severally liable, in their personal individual capacities, to comply with the order.
(iv) The costs of the application.”
2. The application is supported by the affidavit of the Applicant sworn on 10th April 2026 and by grounds on its face. In summary, the Applicant states that the Respondents were served with the order and acknowledged receipt but have contemptuously disregarded it, that she faces a grave and present danger of being prevented by design from enjoying the fruits of the trial court judgment, that the conduct of the Respondents exposes this Court and the trial court to ridicule, that she has no other way of enforcing the order and that it is in the interest of justice that the authority and dignity of this Court be upheld.
3. The Applicant sued the Medical Superintendent of Machakos Level 5 Hospital, the Machakos County Government, the Machakos County Secretary and Machakos Level 5 Hospital in Machakos Chief Magistrate’s Court Civil Suit No. E124 of 2023 (the trial court suit). The suit was filed on 17th March 2023 and sought damages for negligence in the treatment of a fracture of her right ankle.
4. In a judgment delivered on 29th November 2024, Hon. H. M. Mbati, Principal Magistrate, found the defendants liable and awarded general damages of Kshs 280,000 and special damages of Kshs 16,060, with costs and interest at court rates. The decree dated 18th December 2024 stated the sum due as Kshs 302,233, including interest of Kshs 6,173. The certificate of stated costs of the same date certified costs of Kshs 90,600.
5. The Applicant’s advocates demanded payment by a letter dated 19th December 2024, which the Office of the County Attorney stamped as received on 20th December 2024. The decretal sum was not paid and the defendants did not appeal or seek review.
6. The Applicant then moved this Court by a Notice of Motion dated 6th June 2025 for judicial review orders. On 11 March 2026 this Court noted that the Respondents had had ample time to comply but appeared to have adamantly refused or neglected to do so. It allowed the Notice of Motion in terms of prayer 1 and granted an order of mandamus, which was issued on 12th March 2026. The operative part reads:
“1. THAT an order of MANDAMUS be and is hereby granted compelling the Respondents to pay the Applicant herein the decretal sum of Kshs 302,233/= plus costs of Kshs 90,600/= and interest awarded by the Trial Court as per the Decree and certificate of stated costs, both dated 18th December,2024 issued by the Trial Court namely; Machakos Magistrates Court case No. MCCC No. E124 of 2024-Agnes Mwikali Maina vs Medical Superintendent of Machakos Level 5 Hospital, Machakos County Government, Machakos County Secretary, and Machakos Level 5 Hospital.”
7. The order carries a penal notice. On 13th March 2026 the Applicant’s advocates served it by email on the County Attorney and on the County Government’s official email addresses, with a letter warning of contempt proceedings if it was not complied with within twenty-one days. The copy of that letter on the record bears stamps of receipt dated 13th March 2026 from three offices of the County Government, among them the Department of Finance, and a further stamp of the County Solicitor dated 17th March 2026. The order was not obeyed and the Applicant filed the application on 10th April 2026.
8. The Respondents defended the trial court suit through the Office of the County Attorney, Machakos. When the judicial review proceedings came up on 29th October 2025, they proposed sixty days within which to pay the decretal sum and the matter was fixed for mention on 11th March 2026. When the application came up on 14th May 2026, their counsel, Ms Kioko, told the Court that the Respondents did not have the file, that it was in the Finance Department and that payment would be made. She asked that the Respondents be served and said they would respond within seven days. No response was however filed.
9. The substantive motion herein was filed on 6th June 2025 and was allowed by this court on 11th March 2026 when it transpired that the same was not opposed. Thereafter the Ex-parte Applicant prosecuted her case. The Court directed that if payment was made before the ruling date a consent could be filed on the Case Tracking System. None has been filed.
10. Thereafter, the Exparte Applicant filed this application for contempt of court.
Issues for Determination
11. Having considered the application, the supporting affidavit, the evidence and the record, the following issues arise for determination:
(i) Whether the Applicant is entitled to the committal orders sought without a certificate of order against the County Government under section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act, Cap 40.
(ii) What orders should issue.
Analysis and Determination
12. The certificate of order against the Government is provided for by section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act, Cap 40. Section 21(1) provides that:
“Where in any civil proceedings by or against the Government, or in proceedings in connection with any arbitration in which the Government is a party, any order (including an order for costs) is made by any court in favour of any person against the Government, or against a Government department, or against an officer of the Government as such, the proper officer of the court shall, on an application in that behalf made by or on behalf of that person at any time after the expiration of twenty-one days from the date of the order or, in case the order provides for the payment of costs and the costs require to be taxed, at any time after the costs have been taxed, whichever is the later, issue to that person a certificate in the prescribed form containing particulars of the order: Provided that, if the court so directs, a separate certificate shall be issued with respect to the costs (if any) ordered to be paid to the applicant.”(underlining mine).
13. Section 21(3) then places the duty to pay on the accounting officer:
“If the order provides for the payment of any money by way of damages or otherwise, or of any costs, the certificate shall state the amount so payable, and the Accounting Officer for the Government department concerned shall, subject as hereinafter provided, pay to the person entitled or to his advocate the amount appearing by the certificate to be due to him together with interest, if any, lawfully due thereon: Provided that the court by which any such order as aforesaid is made or any court to which an appeal against the order lies may direct that, pending an appeal or otherwise, payment of the whole of any amount so payable, or any part thereof, shall be suspended, and if the certificate has not been issued may order any such direction to be inserted therein.”(underlining mine).
14. Section 21(5) extends the section to county governments:
“This section shall, with necessary modifications, apply to any civil proceedings by or against a county government, or in any proceedings in connection with any arbitration in which a county government is a party.”
15. I am persuaded by the decision of Justice H. I. Ong’udi in the case of Munyiri v Attorney General & another, Petition No. 400 of 2014 [2023] KEHC 22358 (KLR), where a motion to cite a Government officer for contempt was dismissed. The learned Judge held:
“Unmistakably, the respondents’ liability to satisfy the decree under Section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act arose after the Certificate of Order was issued on 13th February 2018”
16. This Court is undoubtedly vested with the power to punish for contempt, as conferred by section 5(1) of the Judicature Act, Cap 8. That power is, however, exercised with circumspection, since committal deprives a person of liberty and is accordingly a measure of last resort. In the case of Republic v Ahmad Abolfathi Mohammed & another, Criminal Application No. 2 of 2018 [2018] eKLR the Supreme Court held that committal is a last resort:
“This power, to commit a person to jail, must be exercised with utmost care, and exercised only as a last resort.”
As a result the procedure for contempt proceedings has been treated by the courts as a matter of substance and not merely of technicality or form, hence requiring the procedure to be followed scrupulously. In the case of Christine Wangari Gachege v Elizabeth Wanjiru Evans & 11 others, Civil Application No. 233 of 2007 [2014] KECA 840 (KLR), the Court of Appeal struck out a similar application for non-compliance with procedure and stated:
“Because in terms of Section 5(2) of the Judicature Act, the court in punishing for contempt exercises ordinary criminal jurisdiction, it is paramount that the procedure for instituting such proceedings be scrupulously followed.”
17. Likewise, in the case of Mutitika v Baharini Farm Ltd, Civil Application No. NAI 24 of 1985 [1985] KLR 229 the Court of Appeal stressed the need for precision where liberty is at stake and stated:
“where the liberty of the subject is, or might be, involved, the breach for which the alleged contemnor is cited must be precisely defined”
18. The instant application and its annexures contain no Certificate of Order against the Respondent. Under section 21(1), the Applicant should have obtained the certificate at any time after twenty-one days from the date of the judgment. Thus, the question now is whether this Court can commit the public officer to prison when the certificate that triggers the accounting officer’s duty under section 21(3) has not been produced. My finding is that the same cannot issue unless and until there is a certificate of order. This application is therefore declined. The same is accordingly struck out with no orders as to costs there having been no opposition to the same.
Orders accordingly.
Ruling dated, signed and delivered virtually via Microsoft teams on this 29th day of October, 2026.
E. N. MAINA
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Ms Mwangi for Muriithi for Exparte Applicant/applicant
No appearance for the Respondent
Miriam – Court Assistant/Interpreter