Civil law

Landmark Holdings Ltd v Boleyn Magic Wall Panel Ltd & another [2026] KEHC 17475 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Case number
Civil Case E003 of 2023
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
E. N. Maina

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By a Plaint dated 1st February 2023, the Plaintiff, Landmark Holdings Limited, sued Boleyn Magic Wall Panel Limited (the 1st Defendant) and Jack Liu (the 2nd Defendant) for judgment against them jointly and severally. The Plaintiff describes itself as a limited liability company carrying on the business of sale of construction materials.

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

On either version the Defendants have not shown that the design change relieved them of their obligation. The Final Account was signed on 5th June 2018 after the alleged change and records the unutilized advance without reservation. DW1 also stated that he stopped production at the end of 2020, long after the accounts with the Plaintiff were closed, and that delivery was completed by 2020. That evidence is inconsistent with a plea that…

Paragraph 39 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS

CIVIL CASE NO. E003 OF 2023

LANDMARK HOLDINGS LIMITED…………………………….PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

BOLEYN MAGIC WALL PANEL LIMITED………………. 1ST DEFENDANT

JACK LIU …………………………………………………… 2ND DEFENDANT

JUDGMENT

1. By a Plaint dated 1st February 2023, the Plaintiff, Landmark Holdings Limited, sued Boleyn Magic Wall Panel Limited (the 1st Defendant) and Jack Liu (the 2nd Defendant) for judgment against them jointly and severally. The Plaintiff describes itself as a limited liability company carrying on the business of sale of construction materials.

2. The Plaintiff pleads that on or about 12th November 2015 it entered into a contract with the Defendants to supply construction materials. Under that agreement the Defendants were to supply precast wall panels, EPS products and other construction materials enumerated in the contract, worth Kshs. 510,353,555/=. The Sales Contract produced names the Plaintiff as buyer and the 1st Defendant as supplier. According to the Plaintiff's submissions, the materials were for its site at Crystal Rivers Estate and Mall, Athi River, which it was constructing on behalf of Safaricom employees.

3. The Plaintiff avers that the Defendants delivered various construction materials over a period of time. After a reconciliation of accounts as at 21st May 2018, which both parties acknowledged in writing by appending their signatures, the Defendants had a balance of Kshs. 50,411,997/= which they owed the Plaintiff in undelivered construction materials. The Plaintiff pleads that the Defendants failed to settle that sum and the parties agreed that they would continue to supply materials to the Plaintiff's various projects, thereby reducing the indebtedness to Kshs. 32,858,664/= as at 7th July 2020. The Defendants then ceased operations altogether.

4. The Plaintiff's claim is for Kshs. 32,786,021/= being the cost of construction materials not delivered. It pleads that demand was made and notice of intention to sue given, and that the Defendants failed, refused or neglected to make good the claim. It prays for judgment against the Defendants jointly and severally for:

(i) the sum of Kshs. 32,786,021/=

(ii) interest on that sum from 7th July 2020 to date

(iii) costs of the suit

(iv) interest at court rates on the foregoing sums

(v) any other relief the court deems fit and just to grant

5. The Plaintiff filed a Reply to the Defendants' Statement of Defence and Defence to Counterclaim dated 9th February 2024. It joined issue with the Defence and prayed that it be struck out and judgment entered as prayed in the Plaint. It denied the Counterclaim save for paragraphs 2, 3, 7, 13 and 14, which it admitted. It admitted paragraph 5 only to the extent that it paid Kshs. 140,000,000/= as the advance payment, and denied that any balance of Kshs. 13,106,066.50 was outstanding. It pleaded that under clause 6 of the Sales Contract the advance payment was to be agreed, interim payments were to follow weekly production and advance recovery was to be pro rata. It denied that the advance was agreed at thirty per cent of the contract price.

6. The Plaintiff further pleaded that the Defendants knew all along that the Sales Contract was subject to the needs and specifications of the developer, Safaricom, from time to time. They were notified by email of the changes and raised no objection. It pleaded that the Defendants were advanced Kshs. 140,000,000/= but were unable to supply materials to exhaust it despite several reminders and indulgences, and that they supplied defective and damaged materials. The Defendants eventually stopped supplying and shut down their factory at Kitengela while still holding a substantial part of the advance. The parties then met and signed an agreement dated 5th June 2018 in which the Defendants admitted owing Kshs. 50,411,997/= as the unutilized advance. Since the Safaricom project had been completed, the Plaintiff allowed the Defendants to supply materials to its other projects, such as the Two Rivers Mall construction site. The Defendants supplied materials worth Kshs. 17,625,976/=, leaving Kshs. 32,786,021/= out of the advance of Kshs. 140,000,000/=. The Plaintiff prayed that the Counterclaim be dismissed with costs and that judgment be entered against the Defendants jointly and severally as prayed in the Plaint.

7. The suit was heard virtually on 12th March 2026. The Plaintiff called one witness, Manjit Singh Sethi (PW1), its Managing Director. He adopted his witness statement dated 1st February 2023 as his evidence in chief and produced the Plaintiff's bundle of documents, items 1 to 8, as exhibits. He stated that the Plaintiff claims Kshs. 32,786,021/= from the Defendants with interest from 7th July 2020. He stated that he was aware of the Counterclaim, that the Plaintiff does not owe the Defendants anything and that the Counterclaim should be dismissed.

8. On cross-examination by Mrs Karanu, learned counsel for the Defendants, PW1 stated that the Plaintiff has been in the construction industry since 1999 and that before the contract in dispute it bought tyres for its motor vehicles from Jack, the 2nd Defendant. He confirmed the contract and stated that the Defendants were supplying precast concrete items such as slabs. A deposit of Kshs. 140 million was to be paid, the parties were to agree on the amount, they agreed, and the Plaintiff paid. The deposit was for the production of the precast items in the Boleyn factory.

9. PW1 stated that the Defendants supplied the precast items only partially. There is a final account showing the amount paid and what was delivered. The Defendants delivered materials worth Kshs. 89,588,003/= and left a balance not delivered of Kshs. 50,411,997/=. He stated that the developer, Safaricom, improved the design, which affected the supply of the precast materials. The change concerned the sizes of some rooms and the layout of the house, and the construction was not changed from precast to blocks and bricks. He stated that the contract was terminated because the Defendants did not perform. He stated that there is a schedule showing how the sum of Kshs. 32,786,021/= arose, being Kshs. 50,411,997/= less what was delivered afterwards. He referred to a letter of 8th December 2020, the last document in the bundle, which shows the outstanding amount. Mrs Karanu remarked that the demand letter had no schedule.

10. In re-examination by Mr. Musundi, learned counsel for the Plaintiff, PW1 stated that the contract was for Kshs. 510,353,555/= for the supply of precast materials such as slabs. Clause 6 provided for payment of a deposit and the Plaintiff paid Kshs. 140 million. The Plaintiff issued several emails asking for progress and then learnt that the factory had been closed. The parties sat down and did a final account on 5th June 2018 showing that the Defendants owed the Plaintiff Kshs. 50,411,997/=. They agreed that the Defendants would continue supplying products to the Plaintiff's other projects, other than Safaricom, which reduced the amount to Kshs. 32,786,021/=. The schedule is in the Plaintiff's bundle. After the Plaintiff issued its demand it received no response, hence this suit. Mr. Musundi then closed the Plaintiff's case.

The Defendants' Case

11. The Defendants filed a Statement of Defence and Counterclaim dated 2nd February 2024. They admitted paragraphs 4, 5, 10 and 11 of the Plaint and denied paragraphs 6, 7, 8 and 9. They pleaded that on 12th November 2015 the 1st Defendant contracted to supply construction materials to the Plaintiff, the main contractor for the construction of Safaricom Villas. In the course of the project, and in breach of the contract, the developer, Safaricom, changed the design of the dining room area and opted for blocks and bricks instead of precast wall panels as agreed between the parties. The Plaintiff then also stopped the 1st Defendant's production of the construction materials as agreed, thereby frustrating the 1st Defendant. The Defendants prayed that the suit be dismissed with costs as an abuse of the court process.

12. In the Counterclaim, the 1st Defendant pleaded as salient terms of the contract a contract price of Kshs. 510,353,555/=, details as per the bill of quantities for three and four bedroom units, payment terms of an advance to be agreed with interim payments according to weekly production based on stocks inventory in the factory stockyard, and an advance payment agreed at thirty per cent of the contract price, that is Kshs. 153,106,066/=. It pleaded that the Plaintiff paid Kshs. 140,000,000/=, leaving an outstanding balance of Kshs. 13,106,066.50. It pleaded that to implement the contract it was mobilized to purchase production lines, formworks, steel stress and supporting transportation vehicles and equipment with the fund of the advance payment, which would be covered by an expected profit margin of thirty per cent.

13. It pleaded that materials worth Kshs. 89,588,003/= were supplied as agreed, that the developer changed the design of the dining room area of the Safaricom villas in breach of the agreement, and that the Plaintiff stopped the production of the construction materials, thereby frustrating the 1st Defendant. The particulars of breach pleaded against the Plaintiff are:

(i) unjustifiably holding funds belonging to the 1st Defendant

(ii) altering the design of the construction project without adequate notice to the 1st Defendant

(iii) failing to pay the sum of Kshs. 89,588,003/= for the materials supplied

(iv) failing to perform the terms of the contract

14. The 1st Defendant prayed for judgment against the Plaintiff for Kshs. 89,588,003/= being construction materials, Kshs. 13,106,066.50 being outstanding deposit, loss of profits, interest and costs.

15. The Defendants called one witness, Jack Liu (DW1), who is the 2nd Defendant and the managing director of the 1st Defendant. He affirmed and testified in English. He adopted his witness statement dated 1st February 2024 as his evidence in chief and produced the Defendants' bundle of three documents. His witness statement repeats the terms pleaded in the Counterclaim. In paragraphs 9, 10 and 11 he states that the 1st Defendant should forfeit the Kshs. 140,000,000/= advance for the loss and damage suffered, that the Plaintiff should pay the outstanding balance of Kshs. 13,106,066.50, and that the Plaintiff should compensate the 1st Defendant Kshs. 89,588,003/= for the construction materials supplied. In paragraph 12 he seeks judgment against the Plaintiff for Kshs. 242,694,069/=. In his oral evidence he stated that the Counterclaim is for Kshs. 89,588,003/= and a further sum of Kshs. 13,106,066.50 being the outstanding deposit.

16. On cross-examination by Mr. Musundi, DW1 stated that the contract was for Kshs. 510 million and that the Defendants delivered materials worth Kshs. 89 million. The deposit was supposed to be thirty per cent of the contract sum, but the Plaintiff paid Kshs. 140 million and left a balance of Kshs. 13,106,066.50. He had no documents with him because he was travelling to Nakuru and his computer was in Nairobi, and his lawyer would prove the matters. He admitted receiving Kshs. 140 million from the Plaintiff and stated that the Defendants did not write to ask for the Kshs. 13,106,066.50. He stated that he had advised his lawyer that the Defendants are not claiming Kshs. 89,588,003/=. He stated that on 5th June 2018 he admitted that he owed the Plaintiff Kshs. 50,411,997/=. He had no documents with him that would support the claim for Kshs. 242,694,069 stated in paragraph 12 of his witness statement.

17. DW1 stated that after signing the contract the Defendants supplied materials. He denied that his factory at Kisaju was auctioned by the bank over unpaid loans and stated that it closed in 2020 and was not advertised for sale. Delivery had already been completed by 2020, the factory was up and running when the contract was entered into and the Defendants did not import equipment. He stated that the Plaintiff changed the design. He stated that the Defendants had a contract for the construction of houses for the police, for which EPS walls were used at Siaya, and asked counsel whether he could prove that he had a contract in Turkana, adding that what counsel was saying was not correct. He stated that the thirty per cent deposit was not paid in full.

18. In re-examination by Mrs Karanu, DW1 stated that the sum of Kshs. 89,588,003/= for construction materials is in the bill of quantities and that the Defendants included it because of the termination of the contract. He stated that the Defendants are not claiming that sum. He did not have his file with him to explain how the Kshs. 13 million arises. Thirty per cent was supposed to be Kshs. 153 million and this is how he arrived at the Kshs. 13 million claimed in prayer 6. He stated that he did the final account on 5th June 2018 and that he stopped production at the end of 2020, long after the accounts with the Plaintiff had been closed. He stated that the sum claimed by the Plaintiff is not payable. Mrs Karanu then closed the Defendants' case.

19. The court directed the parties to file and exchange written submissions. On 11th May 2026 learned counsel for both parties confirmed that they had filed their submissions and the court fixed judgment for 29th October 2026.

The Submissions

The Plaintiff's Submissions

20. The Plaintiff filed written submissions dated 22nd April 2026 together with a list of authorities. Learned counsel identified the following issues for determination:

(i) Whether there existed a valid and enforceable contract between the parties

(ii) Whether the Defendants breached the contract

(iii) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to a refund of Kshs. 32,858,664/= together with interest and costs

21. On the first issue, counsel submitted that a contract may be oral or written provided its essential elements are present. He relied on the case of Pius Kimaiyo Langat v Co-operative Bank of Kenya Limited (Civil Appeal 48 of 2015) [2017] KECA 152 (KLR) for the proposition that once the essential elements are proved the court will enforce the contract. He submitted that the parties signed a binding contract and that there was offer, acceptance, consideration paid and an intention to create legal relations.

22. On the second issue, counsel submitted that the Defendants fundamentally breached the contract by failing to supply precast panels and EPS products to exhaust even the advance of Kshs. 140,000,000/=. When the Plaintiff went to check on the Defendants it found no production taking place and the factory closed, which forced it to use bricks and blocks in place of the precast panels. He submitted that the Defendants' claim that Safaricom changed the design was made without any proof and was a way of avoiding liability for their failure to perform. He submitted that by signing the Final Account dated 5th June 2018 and promising to pay Kshs. 50,411,997/= the Defendants admitted liability, and that failure to supply to the extent of the advance amounts to a total failure of consideration. Counsel relied on the case of National Bank of Kenya Limited v Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Limited & another (Civil Appeal 95 of 1999) [2001] KECA 362 (KLR) for the proposition that parties are bound by the terms of their contract and that failure to perform constitutes breach.

23. On the third issue, counsel submitted that where a party receives money on the basis of a contract and fails to perform the agreed obligations, the money must be refunded. He cited the case of Kenya Tourist Development Corporation v Sundowner Lodge Limited [2018] eKLR for the proposition that an innocent party is entitled to restitution where the other party fails to perform its contractual obligations. He also cited the case of Total Kenya Limited v Jenerams Limited [2015] eKLR for the proposition that retaining money paid under a contract where no services have been rendered amounts to unjust enrichment. He submitted that the Defendants retained Kshs. 32,858,664/= of the advance of Kshs. 140,000,000/= with no legal or equitable justification.

24. On costs, counsel submitted that the Plaintiff was compelled to sue because the Defendants refused to honour their obligations and ignored notices of intention to sue, which are Plaintiff's Exhibits 7 and 8, and that costs follow the event. On interest, he prayed for interest from 5th June 2018, when the Final Account was signed and the sum became due.

25. Responding to the Counterclaim, counsel submitted that clause 6 of the contract states only that the advance payment is required and to be agreed, and that nothing in the contract fixes the advance at thirty per cent. The parties agreed on Kshs. 140,000,000/= which was paid, and the claim for Kshs. 13,106,066.50 is unproven. He submitted that the Kshs. 89,588,003/= claimed as the cost of materials supplied had already been recovered from the advance, as the Final Account shows. The Final Account is Plaintiff's Exhibit 3 and the Defendants' document 3, and the 2nd Defendant signed it. He submitted that the Kshs. 242,694,069/= which DW1 stated was for loss of profits is unsupported by any empirical evidence or data and was plucked from the air.

26. Counsel prayed for judgment against the Defendants jointly and severally for Kshs. 32,858,664/=, interest on the principal sum from 5th June 2018 until payment in full, costs of the suit, and dismissal of the Counterclaim with costs.

The Defendants' Submissions

27. The Defendants filed written submissions dated 8th May 2026. Learned counsel identified the following issues for determination:

(i) Whether there was breach of the terms of the contract dated 12th November 2015 entered into between the Plaintiff and the Defendants

(ii) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to Kshs. 32,786,021/= as claimed in the Plaint

(iii) Whether the Defendants are entitled to the award of Kshs. 89,588,003/= and Kshs. 13,106,066.50 together with interest as sought in the Counterclaim

28. On the first issue, counsel submitted that it is not disputed that there was a valid and binding contract and that failure to perform its obligations amounted to breach. He submitted that the Plaintiff was the first to breach it by remitting Kshs. 140,000,000/= to the 1st Defendant instead of the agreed advance of thirty per cent of the contract price, being Kshs. 153,106,066/=. The Plaintiff and the developer then breached the contract by changing the design of the dining room area and using blocks and bricks instead of the precast wall panels to be supplied by the 1st Defendant, by which time the 1st Defendant had already supplied materials worth Kshs. 89,588,003/=. He submitted that the Plaintiff did not pay for those materials, that performance became impossible and was frustrated by the Plaintiff's conduct, and that the Plaintiff cannot claim against the Defendants when it was the first to breach. He relied on the case of Hydro Water Well (K) Limited v Sechere & 2 others (Sued in their representative capacity as the officers of Chae Kenya Society) (Civil Suit E212 of 2019) [2021] KEHC 22 (KLR) (Commercial and Tax) (10 August 2021) (Judgment) where the High Court held that a claimant for damages must show that a contract existed, that the defendant breached it and that the claimant suffered loss as a result of the breach.

29. On the second issue, counsel submitted that the Plaintiff's witness could not demonstrate how he arrived at the Kshs. 32 million claimed through LPOs, schedules or any documentation. He submitted that special damages must be pleaded with particularity and supported by evidence. He cited the case of National Social Security Fund Board of Trustees v Sifa International Limited [2016] KECA 550 (KLR) in which the Court of Appeal at Mombasa, citing with approval its earlier decision in the case of Coast Bus Service Ltd v Murunga Danyi & 2 others (Civil Appeal 192 of 1992) (UR), held that special damages must be specifically pleaded and strictly proved. Counsel prayed that the Plaintiff's claim fails.

30. On the third issue, counsel submitted that the 1st Defendant incurred Kshs. 89,588,003/= in procuring the works and construction materials required by the Plaintiff for the Safaricom Villas project. The Defendants produced the Final Account of 5th June 2018, which originates from the Plaintiff and lists the works and materials supplied under precast works, EPS floor slab, a Kitengela plain villa precast item and tools to site, totalling Kshs. 89,588,003/=. He submitted that this confirms that the money was utilized and that it is just, fair and equitable that it be repaid. He further submitted that it was a term of the contract that the Plaintiff would pay an advance of thirty per cent of the contract price, being Kshs. 153,106,066/=, and that the Plaintiff does not dispute this. The Plaintiff paid only Kshs. 140,000,000/=, leaving Kshs. 13,106,066.50 which the Defendants claim with interest. He put the total loss caused by the Plaintiff's breach at Kshs. 102,694,069.50.

31. On costs, counsel submitted that it was the Plaintiff's breach of the contract that necessitated the suit and caused the Defendants to incur legal expenses, and that the Plaintiff should bear the costs.

32. In conclusion, counsel urged the court to find that the Plaintiff breached the contract, to dismiss the Plaint and to allow the Counterclaim. He further relied on the case of Banque Indosuez v D.J. Lowe & Company Limited (Civil Appeal 79 of 2002) [2006] KECA 360 (KLR), as cited in the case of Imanyara & 2 others v Attorney General (Civil Appeal 98 of 2014) [2016] KECA 557 (KLR) (19 May 2016) (Judgment), where it was held that special damages must be claimed specially and proved strictly.

Issues for Determination

33. Having considered the pleadings, the evidence and the submissions of both parties, the issues that arise for determination are:

(i) Whether the Defendants breached the contract dated 12th November 2015 and are liable to the Plaintiff for Kshs. 32,786,021/=

(ii) Whether the Defendants have proved the Counterclaim

(iii) What orders should issue on interest and costs

Analysis and Determination

34. The rule that governs the relationship between the parties was stated by the Court of Appeal in the case of National Bank of Kenya Limited v Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Limited & another (supra), in these terms:

“A Court of law cannot re-write a contract between the parties. The parties are bound by the terms of their contract, unless coercion, fraud or undue influence are pleaded and proved.”

35. The Plaintiff bears the burden of proving its claim and the 1st Defendant bears the burden of proving its Counterclaim. Section 107(1) of the Evidence Act, Cap 80 provides that whoever desires the court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist. Section 108 places the burden on the party who would fail if no evidence at all were given on either side, and section 109 places the burden of proof of a particular fact on the person who wishes the court to believe in its existence.

36. The parties are also bound by their pleadings. In the case of Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & another v Stephen Mutinda Mule & 3 others (Civil Appeal 219 of 2013) [2014] KECA 890 (KLR), the Court of Appeal stated:

“parties are bound by their pleadings which in turn limits the issues upon which a trial court may pronounce”

Whether the Defendants breached the contract and are liable for Kshs. 32,786,021/=

37. The following facts are not in dispute. By a Sales Contract dated 12th November 2015 the Plaintiff, as buyer, and the 1st Defendant, as supplier, agreed on the supply of precast wall panels and EPS products for Kshs. 510,353,555/=. The Plaintiff paid Kshs. 140,000,000/= as the advance payment. That is admitted in paragraph 5 of the Counterclaim and by DW1. The parties signed a Final Account dated 5th June 2018, produced by both sides, in which Harveer Sethi for the Plaintiff and Jack Liu for the 1st Defendant acknowledged and confirmed the statement balance as at 21st May 2018. It shows materials worth Kshs. 89,588,003/= against an advance of Kshs. 140,000,000/=, leaving a balance of Kshs. 50,411,997/= in the Plaintiff's favour. DW1 confirmed in cross-examination that on 5th June 2018 he admitted owing that sum.

38. The Defendants' answer is that the developer, Safaricom, changed the design and opted for blocks and bricks, and that the Plaintiff stopped their production, which frustrated performance. There is no evidence to support this. Clause 17 of the Sales Contract required the buyer to inform the supplier in writing of any change in scope due to unforeseen circumstances. The Defendants complain of inadequate notice but produced no document and called no witness from the developer. DW1 stated only that the Plaintiff changed the design. PW1 testified that the change concerned the sizes of some rooms and the layout of the house, and that the construction was not changed from precast to blocks and bricks. Counsel for the Plaintiff submitted that the Plaintiff was forced to use blocks and bricks because the Defendants stopped supplying. Submissions are not evidence, and the sworn testimony of PW1 is the evidence before the court.

39. On either version the Defendants have not shown that the design change relieved them of their obligation. The Final Account was signed on 5th June 2018 after the alleged change and records the unutilized advance without reservation. DW1 also stated that he stopped production at the end of 2020, long after the accounts with the Plaintiff were closed, and that delivery was completed by 2020. That evidence is inconsistent with a plea that the Plaintiff stopped the Defendants' production and frustrated performance. I find that the Defendants failed to supply materials to the value of the advance they received.

40. A claimant must show a contract, a breach by the defendant and loss resulting from the breach. This court is guided by the decision of the Court of Appeal in the case of Haco Industries Limited & another v Doshi Ironmongers Limited & another (Civil Appeal E064 of 2022) [2025] KECA 1604 (KLR), where the court observed that “the denial of breach of the agreement was a challenge to Doshi to prove all the elements that would constitute breach.” The Plaintiff has shown each element. Also, a supplier who fails to deliver cannot keep the advanced deposit paid for the goods, as was the case in Tobias M. Wafubwa v Ben Butali (Civil Appeal 3 of 2016) [2017] KECA 142 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal upheld the refund of a deposit where the seller failed to deliver the goods, stating of the seller that he was not entitled to retain the respondent's deposit.

41. On the amount, I find that the 8th December 2020 demand letter, which counsel for the Defendants observed carried no schedule, is not the sole basis of the claim. The Plaintiff produced evidence to support its claim, including the Final Account signed by the Defendants themselves confirming the balance of Kshs. 50,411,997/=. The Plaintiff pleaded in paragraph 16 of the Reply that this balance was reduced to Kshs. 32,786,021/= by supplies by the Defendants to its other projects, such as Two Rivers Mall, worth Kshs. 17,625,976/=. PW1 produced the schedule and the supporting documents in the Plaintiff's bundle, and DW1 produced no document to contradict them.

42. The Plaint, in paragraph 7 and in PW1's witness statement, mentions Kshs. 32,858,664/= as the indebtedness as at 7th July 2020. The claim in paragraph 8 and prayer (a) is for Kshs. 32,786,021/=, and that is the figure the Reply reconciles. Counsel for the Plaintiff prayed for judgment for Kshs. 32,858,664/= in the submissions. That departs from the pleaded prayer. Following the case of Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & another v Stephen Mutinda Mule & 3 others (supra), the Plaintiff is held to its pleaded claim of Kshs. 32,786,021/=. I find that the sum of Kshs. 32,786,021/= is proved.

43. I disagree with the Defendants' submissions that the claim is for special damages, which relied on the case of National Social Security Fund Board of Trustees v Sifa International Limited (supra) and the case of Coast Bus Service Ltd v Murunga Danyi & 2 others (supra). The claim is for the return of a liquidated advance that was not used for its purpose, and its particulars are in the Final Account, paragraph 16 of the Reply and the schedule produced. Those authorities do not assist the Defendants on the Plaintiff's claim.

44. The Plaintiff sought judgment against the Defendants jointly and severally. The Sales Contract names the 1st Defendant as the supplier and was executed under its stamp. The Final Account was signed by Jack Liu for Boleyn Magic Wall Panel. The Plaint pleads no fraud or other ground for making the 2nd Defendant personally liable, and no evidence was led on it. This court is guided by the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Symon Wairobi Gatuma v Kenya Breweries Ltd & 3 others (Petition E023 of 2023) [2024] KESC 52 (KLR) (30 August 2024) (Judgment), which restated that a company is an artificial person, separate and distinct from its directors and shareholders. The Supreme Court held that:

“The corporate veil can only be pierced or lifted in exceptional circumstances, such as when the court is construing a statute, contract or other document which requires the veil to be lifted; when it can be shown that the company is being used as a mere façade or sham to perpetrate fraud, avoid legal obligations, or achieve some other improper purpose and, when it can be established that the company is an authorized agent of its controllers or its members, corporate or human”

45. None of those exceptions is made out. The Sales Contract does not require the veil to be lifted, nothing shows that the 1st Defendant was used as a façade or sham, and nothing shows that it was the agent of the 2nd Defendant. The Plaintiff's claim against the 2nd Defendant therefore fails. The 1st Defendant is liable to the Plaintiff for Kshs. 32,786,021/=.

Whether the Defendants have proved the Counterclaim

46. The Counterclaim is for Kshs. 89,588,003/=, Kshs. 13,106,066.50 and loss of profits. On the sum of Kshs. 89,588,003/=, DW1 told the court that the Defendants are not claiming it. The Final Account shows that it is the value of the materials the 1st Defendant delivered and that it has been credited against the advance of Kshs. 140,000,000/=, which is how the balance of Kshs. 50,411,997/= arises. Claiming it again would be double recovery. The Defendants' submissions pressing the claim contradict their own witness. It is dismissed.

47. The Kshs. 13,106,066.50 depends on the Defendants' case that the advance was agreed at thirty per cent of the contract price, which is Kshs. 153,106,066/=. Clause 6 of the Sales Contract provides:

“Advance payment required and to be agreed and interim payment according to WEEKLY production based on stocks inventory in the factory stockyard. Advance recovery shall be prorata.”

48. The clause fixes no percentage. The Defendants produced no document showing that thirty per cent was agreed, and DW1 had no file to explain how the figure arises. He admitted that the Plaintiff paid Kshs. 140,000,000/= and that the Defendants never wrote to ask for the balance. The Final Account of 5th June 2018 records the advance as Kshs. 140,000,000/= and mentions no shortfall. The Defendants are bound by the terms of the contract as written, and this court cannot rewrite it, as held in the case of Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Limited (supra). The allegation that the Plaintiff breached the contract first by paying less than the agreed advance is not proved, and the claim for Kshs. 13,106,066.50 is dismissed.

49. The prayer for loss of profits was pleaded without a figure or particulars. DW1's witness statement then seeks Kshs. 242,694,069/=, which equals the total of Kshs. 140,000,000/= that he asks to forfeit, Kshs. 89,588,003/= and Kshs. 13,106,066.50 in paragraphs 9, 10 and 11. The forfeiture of the advance is not pleaded in the Counterclaim, and the Defendants are bound by their pleadings. DW1 admitted that he had no documents to support the figure. The claim is not proved and is dismissed, because loss of profits must be specifically pleaded, as held in the case of Coast Bus Service Ltd (supra), and strictly proved, as the Court of Appeal stated in the case of Banque Indosuez v D.J. Lowe & Company Limited (supra):

“It is trite that special damages must not only be claimed specially but proved strictly”

Interest and costs

50. The Plaintiff prayed for interest from 7th July 2020, and its submissions ask for interest from 5th June 2018. Section 26(1) of the Civil Procedure Act gives the court discretion to order interest at a reasonable rate on the principal sum adjudged from the date of the suit to the date of the decree, and thereafter until payment. I am persuaded by the decision of Justice Mabeya in the case of Patrick Mwaura Wagatira v Equity Bank Limited & another (Civil Case 22 of 2014) [2021] KEHC 6237 (KLR), where the learned judge restated that:

“where a claim is for liquidated damages, unless there is good cause, the interest should be calculated from the date of filing the suit”

51. Interest on Kshs. 32,786,021/= shall therefore run at court rates of 14% per annum from the date of filing of the suit until payment in full.

52. Section 27(1) of the Civil Procedure Act provides that costs follow the event unless the court for good reason orders otherwise. I see no reason to depart from this general position. Accordingly, the Plaintiff has succeeded against the 1st Defendant and the Counterclaim has failed, so the 1st Defendant shall bear the Plaintiff's costs. The 2nd Defendant has succeeded against the claim brought against him and is awarded his costs.

Disposition

53. For the reasons above, I make the following orders:

(a) Judgment is entered for the Plaintiff against the 1st Defendant for Kshs. 32,786,021/=.

(b) Interest on the sum in (a) at court rates of 14% per annum from the date of filing of the suit until payment in full if not agreed in the contract.

(c) The Plaintiff's claim against the 2nd Defendant is dismissed.

(d) The Counterclaim is dismissed with costs to the Plaintiff.

(e) The 1st Defendant shall pay the Plaintiff's costs of the suit and those of the 2nd Defendant.

Orders accordingly.

Judgment dated, signed and delivered virtually via Microsoft teams on this 29th day of October, 2026.

E. N. MAINA

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Ms Mululu for Defendants

Miriam – Court Assistant/Interpreter

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder