REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT AT MACHAKOS
CIVIL APPEAL NO. E021 OF 2026
DIAMOND ACADEMY LTD …….1ST APPELLANT
ROSE WANGUI WAMUGI 2ND APPELLANT
LOIS MURUGI WAMUGI YAMO ..3RD APPELLANT
VERSUS
SUPERIOR HOMES KENYA LTD 1ST RESPONDENT
ABACUS SCHOOL 2ND RESPONDENT
RULING
1. This is a ruling on the Notice of Motion dated 19th February, 2026 brought by the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Appellants (hereafter the Appellants) against the 1st and 2nd Respondents (hereafter the Respondents). It does not address the merits of the appeal, which is yet to be heard. The application is brought under Order 40 Rule 10, Order 42 Rule 6 and Order 51 Rules 1 to 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules and Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act. It seeks a stay of execution of the judgment and decree in Mavoko CMCC No. E869 of 2021 delivered on 22nd January, 2026, pending the hearing and determination of the appeal.
2. The Respondents were the plaintiffs in the lower court. They sued the Appellants for rent arrears of Kshs. 3,934,500 together with contractual interest at 24% per annum from 30th June 2020 until payment in full, arising from a lease of premises at Mavoko used by the 1st Appellant to operate a school. The Appellants filed a defence and a counterclaim, contending that the Respondents retained the Appellants' school chattels and equipment after the lease was surrendered, and sought compensation and orders for their release.
3. On 22nd January, 2026 the trial magistrate entered judgment for the 1st Respondent for Kshs. 3,934,500 together with interest at the contractual rate of 24% per annum from 30th June 2020 until payment in full. The Appellants' counterclaim was dismissed, save for conditional orders on the release of certain goods. The lower court granted a stay of execution of 30 days.
4. The application was opposed by the 1st Respondent. The 2nd Respondent did not file any response. It was subsequently canvassed by way of written submissions.
Grounds of the Application
5. The application is premised on the grounds on the face of the motion, the supporting affidavit sworn on 19th February, 2026 and the further affidavit sworn on 4th June, 2026. The grounds are as follows:
(1) The Appellants are aggrieved by the whole of the judgment delivered in Mavoko CMCC No. E869 of 2021, in which the trial magistrate entered judgment for the 1st Respondent for Kshs. 3,934,500 together with interest at 24% per annum from 30th June 2020, and dismissed the Appellants' counterclaim save for conditional release of certain goods, allegedly in contravention of Article 50 of the Constitution and Sections 109 to 112 of the Evidence Act.
(2) The Appellants claim to be victims of a contravention of the right to a fair hearing guaranteed under Article 50 of the Constitution.
(3) The Appellants have appealed against the entire judgment on grounds that include alleged bias on the part of the trial magistrate, an erroneous shifting of the burden of proof, the refusal of an Anton Piller order sought by the Appellants, and the award of contractual interest.
(4) The trial court is alleged to have disregarded the principle on unconscionable bargains stated in Pius Kimaiyo Langat v The Co-operative Bank of Kenya Limited, Court of Appeal Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2015.
(5) The judgment is alleged to be an arbitrary deprivation of the Appellants' property contrary to Article 40 of the Constitution.
(6) This Court has inherent jurisdiction to grant the orders sought so as to preserve the subject matter of the appeal pending its hearing and determination.
(7) Unless a stay is granted, the 1st Respondent is likely to execute for the decretal sum, exposing the Appellants to substantial loss and rendering the appeal nugatory.
(8) The application has been brought without unreasonable delay and within the period of stay granted by the lower court.
(9) The object of a stay is to preserve the status quo pending the hearing of the appeal so that the appeal is not rendered nugatory.
(10) This Court is required to weigh the relative hardship of the parties and to make the conditions of any stay flexible enough not to shut out litigants of limited means.
(11) The Appellants are ready and willing to abide by any reasonable conditions as to security for the due performance of the decree that this Court may impose.
(12) It is in the interests of justice that the application be allowed as prayed.
6. In her supporting affidavit, Rose Wangui Wamugi deposes that the Appellants were subjected to a biased trial, that the Respondents have continued to trade with the 1st Appellant's chattels since May 2021, and she sets out the grounds in the Memorandum of Appeal. In her further affidavit she avers that paying the decretal sum together with accumulated interest would be financially disastrous, that the 1st Respondent has provided no audited accounts or bank statements to show its capacity to refund the sum, and that the Appellants are prepared and willing to furnish adequate security for the due performance of the decree as this Court may order.
7. In their submissions dated 4th June, 2026, the Appellants contend that this Court has jurisdiction to preserve the subject matter of the appeal, relying on Madhupaper International Limited v Kerr [1985] KLR 840. They invoke Order 40 Rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Rules and the overriding objective, and rely on African Safari Club Limited v Safe Rentals Limited, Court of Appeal at Nairobi Civil Application No.
Nai 53 of 2010 for the weighing of relative hardship. They submit that execution would let the Respondents recover the decretal sum while continuing to hold the Appellants' chattels, so that the appeal would be rendered nugatory, and that Article 48 of the Constitution protects their right of access to the court.
8. The 1st Respondent contends that the application is misconceived and fails the threshold in Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules. It submits that execution is a lawful process and not of itself a ground for stay, citing James Wangalwa & another v Agnes Naliaka Cheseto [2012] eKLR and Joseph Gachie t/a Joska Metal Works v Sion Ndeti Muema [2012] eKLR, that the Appellants have shown no substantial loss by cogent evidence, and that the 1st Respondent is a property developer of known financial standing able to refund the decretal sum. On security it relies on Arun C. Sharma v Ashana Raikundalia t/a Raikundalia & Co. Advocates & 2 others [2014] eKLR, Gianfranco Manini & another v Africa Merchant Assurance Company Ltd [2019] eKLR, Mwaura Karuga t/a Limit Enterprises v Kenya Bus Services Ltd & 4 others [2015] eKLR and Equity Bank Ltd v Taiga Adams Company Limited [2006] eKLR, and submits that no security has been offered. It however concedes that the application "was not brought after inordinate delay" but prays for its dismissal with costs.
Issues for Determination
9. In view of the foregoing, the following issues arise for determination:
(i) Whether the Appellants/Applicants are deserving of the order for stay of execution.
(ii) Who should bear the costs of the application.
Analysis and determination
10. I have carefully considered the application, the affidavits, the rival submissions of the parties, the cases cited, the court record and the law. The jurisdiction to grant a stay of execution pending appeal from a subordinate court is prescribed by Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules. Sub-rule (2) provides:
"No order for stay of execution shall be made under sub rule (1) unless: (a) the Court is satisfied that substantial loss may result to the Applicant unless the order is made and that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and (b) such security as the Court orders for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on him has been given by the Applicant."
11. The three conditions, namely substantial loss, absence of unreasonable delay and the furnishing of security, are cumulative and must all be satisfied before a stay can issue.
Issue (i): Substantial loss and delay
12. What constitutes substantial loss is not defined in the rules. In the case of Century Oil Trading Company Limited V Kenya Shell Limited [2008] KEHC 3680 (KLR) Kimaru J, as he then was, defined substantial loss as follows:
"The word "substantial" cannot mean the ordinary loss to which every judgement debtor is necessarily subjected when he loses his case and is deprived of his property in consequence. That is an element which must occur in every case and since the Code expressly prohibits stay of execution as an ordinary rule it is clear the words "substantial loss" must mean something in addition to all different from that... Where execution of a money decree is sought to be stayed, in considering whether the applicant will suffer substantial loss, the financial position of the applicant and that of the respondent becomes an issue. The Court cannot shut its eyes where it appears the possibility is doubtful of the respondent refunding the decretal sum in the event that the applicant is successful in his appeal. The Court has to balance the interest of the applicant who is seeking to preserve the status quo pending the hearing of the appeal so that his appeal is not rendered nugatory and the interest of the respondent who is seeking to enjoy the fruits of his judgment."
13. The mere fact of execution therefore does not amount to substantial loss. The question is whether the decree holder may be unable to refund the decretal sum should the appeal succeed. On who must prove that, in the case of ABN Amro Bank N v Lemond Foods Limited, Civil Application No. 15 of 2002, cited in the case of Rose Sang Tarus v Barclays Bank of Kenya limited [2021] KELLR 1666 (KLR), the Court of Appeal stated:
“the legal burden still remains on the applicant, but the evidential burden would then have shifted to the respondent to show that he would be in a position to refund the decretal sum if it is paid out to him and the pending appeal was to succeed.”
14. Applying that principle to this case, the 1st Respondent's assertion that it is a property developer of known financial standing is a bare statement. No audited accounts, bank statements, title documents or other evidence of its capacity to refund the decretal sum have been placed before this Court. The evidential burden identified in the case of ABN Amro Bank v Lemond Foods Limited (supra). In my view, substantial loss within the meaning of Order 42 Rule 6(2)(a) of the Civil Procedure Rules, has therefore been established.
Timeousness of the Application
15. The judgment was delivered on 22nd January, 2026 and the lower court granted a stay for 30 days. The Certificate of Urgency is dated 18th February, 2026 and the Notice of Motion 19th February, 2026, the application was therefore made without unreasonable delay.
Security for the due performance of the decree
16. Security is a mandatory condition under Order 42 Rule 6(2)(b) of the Civil Procedure Rules. Its purpose is to guarantee the due performance of the decree and not to punish the judgment debtor. In weighing the relative hardship of the parties and fashioning the terms of a stay, the Court of Appeal stated in the case of African Safari Club Limited v Safe Rentals Limited (supra):
“With the above scenario of almost equal hardship by the parties it is incumbent upon the Court, pursuant to the overriding objective to act justly and fairly. The first role we have undertaken in this regard is to consider the hardships of the two parties before us. The second role is to put the hardship on the scales.”
17. In the above case the Court of Appeal treated the form and terms of security as a matter for the Court's discretion, having regard to the circumstances of each case.
The 1st Respondent submits that no security was offered. That overlooks paragraphs 12 and 16 of the Appellants' further affidavit, in which they state that they are prepared and willing to furnish adequate security for the due performance of the decree as this Court may order. Because the interest rate is itself a live ground of appeal, the interests of justice will be met by requiring the Appellants to deposit the entire decretal sum, as a condition of the stay.
Issue (ii): Costs
18. The costs of an interlocutory application of this nature ordinarily abide the outcome of the appeal. I see no reason to depart from that practice.
Disposition
19. The application dated 19th February, 2026 is merited and is allowed on the following terms:
(a) There shall be a stay of execution of the Judgment and Decree of the Magistrate's Court delivered on 22nd January, 2026 in Mavoko CMCC No. E869 of 2021, pending the hearing and determination of the Appellants' appeal herein.
(c) As security for the stay granted the Appellants shall, within 30 days of the date of this ruling, deposit the entire decretal sum either, in an interest earning account in the joint names of the advocates for the Appellants and the 1st Respondent or in court.
(c) In default of compliance with order (b) within the stipulated period, the stay shall automatically lapse and the 1st Respondent shall be at liberty to execute the decree without further reference to this Court.
(d) The costs of this application shall abide the outcome of the appeal.
Orders accordingly.
Ruling dated, signed and delivered virtually via Microsoft teams on this 29th day of October, 2026.
E. N. MAINA
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Mr. Ndung’u Kuria for Kamau Kuria for the Applicant
Mr. Mwangi for Miss Yala for 1st Respondent
Miriam – Court Assistant/Interpreter